Six Degrees of Separation: From I Want Everything to Soot

It’s the first Saturday of the month which means it’s time for another Six Degrees of Separation, hosted by Kate of Books are my Favourite and Best. The idea is that Kate chooses a book to use as a starting point and then we have to link it to six other books of our choice to form a chain. A book doesn’t have to be connected to all of the others on the list – only to the one next to it in the chain.

This month we’re starting with I Want Everything by Dominic Amerena. I haven’t read it, but here’s what it’s about:

You all know this, of course, but years and years ago, acclaimed Australian novelist Brenda Shales went missing. After two explosive, controversial books that would shape the literary canon of the country for decades to come — and that terrible legal scandal about plagiarism, of course — she was simply gone.

That was, right up until a frustrated young writer sees an elderly woman swimming at his local pool in Melbourne. She looks familiar…very familiar in fact. No. It couldn’t be. Stunned, he returns home to confirm the impossible truth; it’s Brenda Shales, now in her old age and stranded in a retirement home. He’s determined to pursue her, to discover what happened to her all those years ago, and to possibly fulfil his dreams of literary stardom through a tell-all biography. But when he finds her, a case of mistaken identity and Brenda’s own terrible secrets begin to derail his ambitions, and ultimately, his entire life.

~

I’m going to begin this month’s chain with another book about an author who goes missing. In Death of an Author by ECR Lorac (1), the reclusive crime writer Vivian Lestrange disappears without trace, leaving the police questioning whether he ever really existed in the first place. This is the only book I’ve read by Lorac so far and I enjoyed it, although I think it probably wasn’t the best one I could have started with – I must read another one soon!

Now a simple link using the word ‘Death’. Death in Cyprus by MM Kaye (2) is one of a series of romantic suspense novels set in different parts of the world. In this one, Amanda Derington visits Cyprus while accompanying her uncle on a business trip. Before the ship even arrives at the port, a murder has taken place and Amanda finds herself the next target. The books are all standalone stories and can be read in any order – this is one of my favourites.

Another book set in Cyprus is The Sunrise by Victoria Hislop (3). The story takes place in Famagusta in 1974, when a luxury hotel, the Sunrise, is evacuated during a Greek military coup and Turkish invasion. Although I found the book quite unevenly paced, I did love the setting and the descriptions of the abandoned city in the aftermath of the invasion.

Amor Towles’ A Gentleman in Moscow (4) is another book with a hotel setting. It tells the story of a Russian Count who is sentenced to spend the rest of his days under house arrest in Moscow’s Metropol Hotel. I loved this book and found it very inspiring to see how the Count managed to lead such a fulfilling life during his confinement.

Room by Emma Donoghue (5) also deals with confinement. It’s narrated by five-year-old Jack, who is being held captive with his mother inside a single room and has never seen the outside world. Although the plot is quite disturbing and it also took me a while to get used to Jack’s narrative voice, I eventually became gripped.

Like Room, Andrew Martin’s Soot (6) has a four letter title with a double o in the middle. This is the only similarity, though, as this book is a mystery set in 18th century York and revolving around the murder of a painter of silhouettes. I really enjoyed this book, so it’s a good place to end my chain!

~

And that’s my chain for this month. My links have included: missing authors, the word ‘death’, Cyprus, hotels, confinement and four letter titles.

In November we’ll be starting with We Have Always Lived in the Castle by Shirley Jackson – at last, a book that I’ve actually read!

The Predicament by William Boyd

After finishing last year’s Gabriel’s Moon, I was pleased to learn that William Boyd was writing a second book about Gabriel Dax. I’ve now read it and enjoyed it even more than the first.

The Predicament begins in March 1963 with travel writer Gabriel trying to lead a peaceful life in a small East Sussex village. However, his parallel life in the world of espionage just won’t leave him alone. His Russian contact, Natalia Arkadina of the KGB, still believes he is a double agent working on behalf of Russia and has requested a meeting with him to give him his latest assignment. Meanwhile, Faith Green of MI6 has also approached him with a new mission: to go to Guatemala and interview Padre Tiago, the man expected to win the upcoming presidential election there.

Gabriel is not thrilled about getting involved in spying again, but agrees to the Guatemala plan as he’ll be able to combine the trip with some research for his new book on the world’s rivers. Unfortunately, things go badly wrong and he leaves the country in a hurry, having made himself the target of some unscrupulous people. It’s not long before he is given a new task, though – this time he must go to Germany and try to prevent an assassination attempt on President Kennedy, who is visiting West Berlin.

I don’t often choose to read spy thrillers, but one of the things I find compelling about this series is that Gabriel is such a reluctant and accidental spy. He never intended to get mixed up in international espionage and is really not very good at it! We do see him adding to his skill set in this book, though, being trained on how to lose someone who is trying to follow him and how to use everyday items as weapons. And although his Guatemala mission is disastrous, he does play a part in foiling the conspiracy to kill JFK in Berlin (I’m sure it’s not a spoiler to say that it was foiled as everyone knows that he wasn’t assassinated in Germany). Boyd does a good job of creating tension in the Berlin sections, despite it already being obvious what the outcome is going to be!

Gabriel’s Moon probably had slightly more depth, as it also featured a storyline about a childhood trauma that affected Gabriel’s mental health, but I preferred this book overall – possibly because when I read the first one I was comparing it unfavourably with Boyd’s previous and very different novel, The Romantic, which I loved. And although the mental health storyline is pushed into the background in this book, Gabriel does find himself facing some other personal predicaments: he is being accused of plagiarism by another travel author, who is not pleased that Gabriel has written about the same group of islands; his ex-girlfriend Lorraine is trying to rekindle their relationship; and Gabriel himself is continuing to struggle with his feelings for his MI6 handler, Faith Green. Faith is an enigmatic character – is she really romantically interested in Gabriel or is she just stringing him along for her own purposes?

The Predicament is an entertaining read with some fascinating settings – Guatemala on the brink of a political revolution and post-war Berlin shortly after the construction of the Berlin Wall. Throughout the book, Gabriel’s Russian contacts, Natalia and Varvara, keep pushing for him to also visit Moscow, so maybe that will finally happen in the next book! This is apparently intended to be a trilogy, so hopefully we’ll get answers to some of the other questions in the final novel too. Something to look forward to.

Thanks to Viking for providing a copy of this book for review via NetGalley.

My Commonplace Book: September 2025

A selection of quotes and pictures to represent September’s reading:

commonplace book
noun
a book into which notable extracts from other works are copied for personal use.

~

‘The pandemic was such a strange time,’ she murmured. ‘Everyone in the world lived through a nightmare. So much uncertainty and fear for the future. We couldn’t take anything for granted. Not even in Midwinter. A village like nowhere else.’

Miss Winter in the Library with a Knife by Martin Edwards (2025)

~

Ohio buckeye tree

Therein, she thought, lies the unbearable solitude of a lie: you’re alone when you tell it, alone when you live it, alone when you try to dismantle it.

Buckeye by Patrick Ryan (2025)

~

Kuzunoha may be shown looking sorrowful and with her head downcast, but her eyes are wide open. And neither of them has been painted in. If the finishing touches are the most important part of a painting, then looking at this one will really show you just how important the eyes are to a human face.

Murder at the Black Cat Cafe by Seishi Yokomizo (1947)

~

‘That’s life, Gabriel. None of us knows the full consequences of our decisions. History is the history of unintended consequences. Life is random, unpredictable.’

The Predicament by William Boyd (2025)

~

Eurasian woodcock

It grew late, later than Mattis usually stayed up. All the same, he didn’t feel like going to bed, and went on strolling about outside. When you had something on your mind it was even worse, lying in bed twisting and turning.

The Birds by Tarjei Vesaas (1957)

~

Poems take us to all kinds of strange and surprising intimacies in the past; they invite us into unexpected empathy with individuals and moments far away.

A History of England in 25 Poems by Catherine Clarke (2025)

~

Favourite books read in September:

Buckeye, A History of England in 25 Poems, The Predicament and The Birds

Authors read for the first time in September:

Patrick Ryan, Catherine Clarke, Tarjei Vesaas

Places visited in my September reading:

England, US, Japan, Guatemala, Germany, Norway

~

Reading notes: This was another slower month for me in terms of the number of books I finished, but I enjoyed them all and loved most of them, which is the most important thing. It was also good to discover some new authors and to add Guatemala, a completely new setting for me, to my list of countries visited! I read two books that counted towards the RIP XX challenge and have lots more lined up for October – although I don’t know how many I’ll have time for because October also means 1925 Club, the latest club year hosted by Karen and Simon, which is always something to look forward to!

What did you read in September? Do you have any plans for October?

Murder at the Black Cat Cafe by Seishi Yokomizo

Translated by Bryan Karetnyk

Over the last few years, Pushkin Press have been publishing Seishi Yokomizo’s Kosuke Kindaichi mysteries in new English translations. This is the latest, but I found it different from the previous ones in several ways.

First, where the other books are full-length novels, Murder at the Black Cat Cafe is a novella (this edition also includes another short story, Why Did the Well Wheel Creak?, to make the book more substantial). Yokomizo’s detective, Kosuke Kindaichi, plays a prominent role in the first story, but a very small one in the second – in fact, I wouldn’t really call that one a Kindaichi mystery at all as he only appears right at the end. Both stories belong to the type Yokomizo refers to in the prologue as ‘faceless corpse’ mysteries – in other words, where the murder victim has had their face destroyed so they can’t be identified.

The other main difference is in the setting. Usually the Kindaichi mysteries are set in rural Japan – a small village, a country house, a remote island – but Murder at the Black Cat Cafe has a city setting: Tokyo’s red-light district, an area known as the Pink Labyrinth. First published in 1947, the story takes place just after the war and begins with a policeman on patrol discovering the faceless body of a woman in the garden of the Black Cat Cafe, an establishment owned until very recently by the Itojimas, who have just sold it and moved away. Beside the corpse is the body of a black cat, which has also been killed. It’s assumed that the cat is the famous mascot of the Cafe – until the Cafe’s black cat emerges alive and well. Where did the other cat come from and who is the dead woman?

I enjoyed the post-war urban setting, but with the second story, Why Did the Well Wheel Creak?, we are back on more familiar ground with a family living in a remote village. The patriarch, Daizaburo, has two sons – one legitimate and one illegitimate – who are almost identical apart from their eyes. When both young men go to war and only one returns alive, having lost both eyes, questions begin to be asked. Is this man who he says he is or could he be pretending to be his brother?

Both of these stories, then, feature mistaken or stolen identities and people who may or may not be impostors and both have enough twists and turns to keep the reader guessing until the truth is revealed. The first one was probably the stronger mystery, but I did enjoy the second one as well and liked the way the story unfolded through letters sent from a sister to her brother. I’m already looking forward to the next Kindaichi book, She Walks at Night, coming next year.

Thanks to Pushkin Vertigo for providing a copy of this book for review via NetGalley.

Book 2 for RIP XX

A History of England in 25 Poems by Catherine Clarke

If you had to choose a selection of poems to represent your country’s past, which ones would you pick? What can poetry teach us about a nation’s history, culture and identity? These are some of the questions Catherine Clarke sets out to answer in this wonderful new book which tells the story of England through twenty-five famous and not-so-famous poems.

Beginning with the 8th century poem Cædmon’s Hymn, written in Old English, the book then moves chronologically through time, ending with Zaffar Kunial’s The Groundsman from 2022. Familiar names including Geoffrey Chaucer, Shakespeare, Tennyson and Lewis Carroll are all represented, but so are some lesser known poets from more diverse backgrounds such as Phillis Wheatley, the first African-American woman to have her poems published, and Grace Nichols, an immigrant to Britain from Guyana. The poems have all been selected for what they can tell us about specific moments in English history: Viking raids, the Battle of Agincourt, the plague, the miners’ strikes, the Great Storm of 1987 and many more.

Before picking up this book, it’s important to know that it shouldn’t really be approached as simply a poetry anthology. Not all of the poems appear in full – many are just extracts – and they haven’t necessarily been chosen for the beauty of the language. The literary merit of each poem is discussed only briefly or not at all, as Clarke is more interested in the life of the writer, why they chose to write that particular poem at that particular time and how the poem fits into the wider context of what was happening in England during that period. Each poem is given its own chapter and with twenty-five of them to get through, the chapters are relatively short, although still long enough to say everything that needs to be said.

I enjoyed every chapter – although I was already familiar with most of the historical figures and topics discussed in the book, it was interesting to see them from different, unusual perspectives and to discover some new poems I’d never read before. Some of my favourites were Mary Leapor’s Crumble Hall, written through the eyes of a servant in an 18th century country house; Adlestrop by Edward Thomas, describing a train briefly stopping at a station in 1914; and Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s The Cry of the Children, a protest against child labour during the Industrial Revolution.

I can highly recommend this book to anyone with an interest in English history. If you also like poetry it would be helpful, but not essential! I thought it was a fascinating approach and it would be good to read about another country’s history seen through the lens of its poetry like this.

Thanks to Penguin Classics/Allen Lane for providing a copy of this book via NetGalley.

Miss Winter in the Library with a Knife by Martin Edwards

I was drawn to this book by the title and cover and as I’d been wanting to give Martin Edwards another try – I didn’t really get on with Mortmain Hall – I decided to read it. I’m pleased to say that I really enjoyed this one!

Harry Crystal, who narrates part of the story, is the author of thirty-two mystery novels. When online influencer Carys Neville describes his books as ‘dozy crime’ and accuses him of being an Agatha Christie copycat, Harry finds himself dropped by his publisher. Receiving an invitation from the Midwinter Trust inviting him to spend Christmas in the village of Midwinter and participate in a murder mystery game with a cash prize for the winner, Harry decides to accept. After all, he doesn’t have much else to do and winning something would help him to feel less of a failure.

Midwinter, considered one of the most remote settlements in England, is a tiny former mining village in the North Pennines. Privately owned by the Midwinter Trust, it’s advertised as a place to retreat from the outside world. Harry arrives during a period of heavy snow to find that the village really has been completely cut off from the rest of the world, with no phone or internet access. To his dismay, Carys Neville is one of the other contestants, along with four other people, all of whom are involved in some way with publishing or crime writing. Winning the prize isn’t going to be as easy as he’d hoped!

Miss Winter in the Library with a Knife is the title of the mystery put together by Trust director Bernadette for the six guests to solve. Clues and evidence relating to this fictional mystery are given in separate chapters titled Bonus Puzzle Content. The reader can try to solve this mystery for themselves, as well as a ‘real’ mystery which begins to unfold involving the guests, staff and Trust members. However, this structure didn’t work quite as well as I expected; the mystery-within-a-mystery feels undeveloped and is referred to less and less often as the book goes on so that when the solution was eventually revealed, I didn’t really care – and it seemed that the players didn’t either.

The Midwinter storyline was much more compelling than the Miss Winter one. I loved the setting and Edwards does a great job of conveying how remote and isolated the village is, beginning with the atmospheric drive from the station across deserted snowy moorland. Although I felt that some of the characters could have been stronger, I enjoyed the sections written from the perspectives of Harry Crystal and another of the guests, the publicist Poppy de Lisle. It’s not clear who can and can’t be believed, what the true motives of the Trust are or why these particular six guests have been invited to Midwinter, so there’s a lot to unravel.

Edwards is clearly a big fan of Golden Age mysteries (he’s the editor of the British Library Crime Classics series) and the influence of Christie and other authors is obvious here. He also includes a Cluefinder – a device sometimes used in GA mysteries – at the end of the book, listing all the clues that appeared throughout the story with references to the chapter they are found in. Unfortunately, I hadn’t spotted many of those!

I didn’t love everything about this book, then, but I did find it very entertaining and was surprised by some of the plot twists towards the end. It would be a perfect book to read during a winter snowstorm.

Thanks to Aria & Aries for providing a copy of this book for review via NetGalley.

Book 1 for RIP XX

Historical Musings #92: HWA Crown Awards 2025

Welcome to this month’s post on all things historical fiction!

This month, I want to highlight the books nominated for this year’s HWA Crown Awards. The longlists were announced last Wednesday by the Historical Writers Association (HWA) and you can find all the details here. There are three separate awards – one for debut novels, one for non-fiction and the other (the Gold Crown) for authors who have previously published. The shortlists will be announced in October and the winner in November. Although I don’t have any plans to try to read all of these books, I thought it would be interesting to look at what I’ve read so far from each list and what else I might like to read.

Debut Crown 2025 longlist

The Wicked of the Earth by AD Bergin
Costanza by Rachel Blackmore
The Instrumentalist by Harriet Constable
Nephthys by Rachel Louise Driscoll
Murder in Constantinople by AE Goldin
Spitting Gold by Carmella Lowkis
Winter of Shadows by Clare Grant
A Poisoner’s Tale by Cathryn Kemp
The Eights by Joanna Miller
A Little Trickerie by Rosanna Pike
They Dream in Gold by Mai Sennaar
A Case of Mice and Murder by Sally Smith

I’ve read four of these and enjoyed all of them, particularly A Little Trickerie and A Case of Mice and Murder. I’ve already read the second book in Sally Smith’s series as well, and would be happy to read more books by the other three authors. Most of the others on the list are books that I’ve heard of but haven’t had a chance to read yet, with one or two that are new to me.

Non-Fiction Crown 2025 longlist

Lionessheart by Catherine Hanley
The Scapegoat by Lucy Hughes-Hallett
The Endless Country by Sami Kent
Demon of Unrest by Erik Larson
Naples 1944 by Keith Lowe
Storm’s Edge by Peter Marshall
Agent Zo by Clare Mulley
Moederland by Cato Pedder
Every Living Thing by Jason Roberts
The Women’s Orchestra of Auschwitz by Anne Sebba
The Many Lives of James Lovelock by Jonathan Watts
The Grammar of Angels by Edward Wilson-Lee

Not surprisingly I’ve read none of the books on this list and have only heard of one or two of them. The subjects seem a lot more varied than last year’s list and there are a few books here that interest me, particularly The Scapegoat, about the life of the Duke of Buckingham.

Gold Crown Award 2025 longlist

The Heart in Winter by Kevin Barry
Shy Creatures by Clare Chambers
The Small Museum by Jody Cooksley
Man of Bones by Ben Creed
Small Bomb at Dimperley by Lissa Evans
Arthur by Giles Kristian
The Maiden of Florence by Katherine Mezzacappa
Hold Back the Night by Jessica Moor
The Map of Bones by Kate Mosse
The Stolen Daughter by Florence Olájídé
The American Daughters by Maurice Carlos Ruffin
Time of the Child by Niall Williams

I can’t believe I’ve only read one of these! I’ve read the sequel to The Small Museum, The Surgeon’s House, which was published this year and am not really interested in going back to read the first one, and I’ve struggled with Kate Mosse in the past, but the rest of the books all sound interesting.

~

What do you think of this year’s longlists? Have you read any of these books or would you like to read them?