Historical Fiction Reading Challenge: Looking back at 2024 and forward to 2025!

17 Comments

I don’t often take part in year-long reading challenges as I prefer to just join in with shorter reading events these days. However, there’s still one that I like to participate in every year – and that is the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge, hosted by Marg at The Intrepid Reader & Baker. Although it’s not really very challenging for me as I read a lot of historical fiction anyway, I do enjoy linking my reviews to the monthly challenge posts, seeing what other participants are reading and discovering new historical fiction novels and bloggers. Marg has also been posting monthly statistics so we can see which books and authors are proving particularly popular.

Before I post the details of the 2025 challenge, I want to look back at what I achieved in 2024.

I had signed up at the ‘Prehistoric’ level, which meant reading 50+ historical fiction novels during the year. I managed to read 57 (six more than last year’s 51) and here they are, with links to my reviews where available:

1. Silence by Shūsaku Endō
2. The Beholders by Hester Musson
3. The Spendthrift and the Swallow by Ambrose Parry
4. Cuddy by Benjamin Myers
5. The Bone Hunters by Joanne Burn
6. The Fox Wife by Yangsze Choo
7. Clairmont by Lesley McDowell
8. The Warm Hands of Ghosts by Katherine Arden
9. The Life of Rebecca Jones by Angharad Price
10. The Tower by Flora Carr
11. The Trumpet-Major by Thomas Hardy
12. The Book of Secrets by Anna Mazzola
13. The Reckoning by Sharon Penman
14. The Ballad of Lord Edward and Citizen Small by Neil Jordan
15. The Fraud by Zadie Smith
16. The Household by Stacey Halls
17. A Plague of Serpents by KJ Maitland
18. Hungry Ghosts by Kevin Jared Hosein
19. Spitting Gold by Carmella Lowkis
20. The Ballad of Jacquotte Delahaye by Briony Cameron
21. The House of Doors by Tan Twan Eng
22. The Burial Plot by Elizabeth Macneal
23. The Nightingale’s Castle by Sonia Velton
24. The Meiji Guillotine Murders by Futaro Yamada
25. The Puzzle Wood by Rosie Andrews
26. Babylonia by Costanza Casati
27. A Woman of Opinion by Sean Lusk
28. The King’s Mother by Annie Garthwaite
29. The Trouble with Mrs Montgomery Hurst by Katie Lumsden
30. A Case of Mice and Murder by Sally Smith
31. The Elusive Pimpernel by Baroness Orczy
32. House of Shades by Lianne Dillsworth
33. The King’s Witches by Kate Foster
34. The Briar Club by Kate Quinn
35. In the Upper Country by Kai Thomas
36. A Court of Betrayal by Anne O’Brien
37. The Hazelbourne Ladies Motorcycle and Flying Club by Helen Simonson
38. The Golden Tresses of the Dead by Alan Bradley
39. Cabaret Macabre by Tom Mead
40. A Little Trickerie by Rosanna Pike
41. The King’s Messenger by Susanna Kearsley
42. Precipice by Robert Harris
43. Mary I: Queen of Sorrows by Alison Weir
44. Midnight in Vienna by Jane Thynne
45. God is an Englishman by RF Delderfield
46. The Glassmaker by Tracy Chevalier
47. The Bells of Westminster by Leonora Nattrass
48. The Lost Queen by Carol McGrath
49. Black Hearts in Battersea by Joan Aiken
50. City of Silk by Glennis Virgo
51. Poor Girls by Clare Whitfield
52. The Royal Rebel by Elizabeth Chadwick
53. Gabriel’s Moon by William Boyd
54. The Ghost of Madison Avenue by Nancy Bilyeau
55. What Time the Sexton’s Spade Doth Rust by Alan Bradley
56. The Voyage Home by Pat Barker
57. Absolutely and Forever by Rose Tremain

Now, here are the rules for the 2025 challenge, taken from Marg’s blog:

Any sub-genre of historical fiction is accepted (Historical Romance, Historical Mystery, Historical Fantasy, Young Adult, History/Non-Fiction, etc.)

During the following 12 months you can choose one of the different reading levels:

20th Century Reader – 2 books
Victorian Reader – 5 books
Renaissance Reader – 10 books
Medieval – 15 books
Ancient History – 25 books
Prehistoric – 50+ books

You can sign up for the challenge here. I will be aiming for Prehistoric again in 2025.

Let me know if you’re planning to take part too!

Third Girl by Agatha Christie

11 Comments

This is the final book I’ve read for this year’s Read Christie challenge. I had intended to read it in November, but didn’t have time. I’m glad I’ve still managed to fit it in before the end of the year because, although I don’t think it’s one of Christie’s absolute best, I did enjoy reading it.

Norma Restarick is the ‘third girl’ of the title. The term refers to the practice of two girls who are living together in rented housing advertising for a third girl to take the spare room and share the rent with them. Norma crosses paths with Hercule Poirot when she approaches him for help because she thinks she may have committed murder – but after meeting Poirot in person, she flees, saying she’s made a mistake and he is too old to be of assistance.

Concerned – and insulted – Poirot tries to find out the reason for Norma’s visit to him and learns that the girl is acquainted with his friend, the mystery writer Ariadne Oliver. This makes it possible for Poirot, with Mrs Oliver’s help, to track down Norma’s family at their home in the country and the two girls she lives with in London. But Poirot is still confused. Norma says she thinks she has tried to poison her stepmother because a bottle of weed killer has been found in her room, yet she has no memory of actually doing it. It’s also not the only time Norma has experienced gaps in her memory. Convinced he doesn’t have all the facts and that the murder Norma originally referred to was not the attempted one she’s now confessing to, Poirot begins to investigate.

A common theme in Christie’s later books seems to be that society is changing and the world is moving on and she doesn’t like or understand it. Published in 1966, this book is firmly set in the 1960s and the older characters take every opportunity to complain about the fashions (particularly men with long hair), the music, the culture and what they see as rampant drug use amongst young people. I found this interesting as it gives the book a very different feel from the earlier Poirot novels. I think Poirot, like Christie herself, probably felt much more at home in the 1930s!

Third Girl is also unusual because for most of the book we don’t know if a murder has actually been committed and if so, who the victim is. This makes it less of a conventional detective novel and more of a psychological study of Norma Restarick. As we learn more about Norma’s past, there’s a real sense of her vulnerability and how she could be being manipulated by other people. Even when the true nature of the crime that needed to be investigated became clearer, I still didn’t correctly guess who the culprit was – and to be honest, I thought it was quite an unconvincing solution, which relied on several of the characters being very unobservant.

What I did love about this book is that Ariadne Oliver plays such a big part in it from beginning to end. She is often said to represent Christie herself and gives her a chance to comment on the writing of detective novels! It’s always nice to see her pop up in a Poirot mystery and I wish she was in more of them. In Third Girl, Mrs Oliver adds some humour to the book, as well as inadvertently providing Poirot with some of the key clues. Poirot is also present from the beginning of the book, rather than appearing halfway through as he often does.

I’m pleased to have completed eight of the twelve monthly reads for the 2024 Read Christie challenge. I’m looking forward to joining in again in 2025!

Merry Christmas!

20 Comments

Just a quick post to wish a Merry Christmas to those who celebrate it – and for those who don’t, I hope you have a lovely day anyway!

Thank you to everyone who has read, liked or commented on my reviews throughout the year. It’s very much appreciated! Have a great Christmas and I’ll be back soon with one or two more posts before the end of the month.

The Ghost of Madison Avenue by Nancy Bilyeau

11 Comments

Christmas is always a good time to read ghost stories, I think! This one is even set in December – and is also a novella, which makes it a good choice if you’re looking for something quick to read over the Christmas holidays.

The story takes place in New York in December 1912. Helen O’Neill is part of an Irish-American family from the Bronx and since being widowed several years earlier she has been living with her two older brothers. Helen is determined not to be a financial burden on her family and has been working at the Metropolitan Museum of Art where she has proved to have a talent for restoration. She’s so good at it, in fact, that she catches the attention of the librarian Belle da Costa Greene, who entices her away from the museum with the offer of a job in the private library of the financier J.P. Morgan.

Starting work at the Morgan Library on Madison Avenue, Helen is captivated by the beautiful building with its thick bronze doors, marble rotunda and exquisite murals. But in the street outside, she sees something even more memorable – a young woman in old-fashioned dress, inappropriate for the cold winter weather, who suddenly disappears without trace. As the days go by, Helen has several more encounters with this strange girl whom only she seems able to see. Eventually, she begins to ask herself whether the girl could be a ghost and if so, is she trying to tell Helen something?

Even without the supernatural element, The Ghost of Madison Avenue is a fascinating piece of historical fiction. Morgan, of course, was a real person and his library on Madison Avenue can still be visited, but so was Belle da Costa Greene, a woman I’d never heard of but who seems to have led an interesting life. As I read, I kept thinking that she really deserved a novel of her own, then I discovered that at least two have already been written! They are The Personal Librarian by Marie Benedict and Victoria Christopher Murray and Belle Greene by Alexandra Lapierre.

As a ghost story, I thought the book was less successful. Not all ghost stories are scary (and not all need to be), but I didn’t find this one even a little bit eerie. It’s more of a story about Helen’s grief – she has never really come to terms with her husband’s death – and laying to rest the ghosts of her past so that she can finally move on with her life. I also found the book too short to be completely satisfying. A longer novel would have allowed Bilyeau to expand on some of the other topics she touched on, such as the aes sidhe of Irish mythology, and Helen’s relationship with her sister Bernadette, who has become a nun.

Still, I enjoyed this book and it didn’t take long to read! I’ve now read everything currently published by Nancy Bilyeau and will look forward to her next book in the Genevieve Planché series, hopefully coming next year.

Book 54 for the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge 2024

A House on the Rhine by Frances Faviell – #DeanStreetDecember24

12 Comments

My previous experience with Frances Faviell has been limited to her Second World War memoir, A Chelsea Concerto, so I was curious to see what her novels were like. There are several currently available from Dean Street Press and as Liz is hosting her Dean Street December event this month, I decided it was a good time to give one of them a try.

A House on the Rhine, first published in 1955, tells the story of a family trying to adjust to life in postwar Germany. After their home was destroyed during the war, the family – Joseph and Moe and their twelve children – spent four and a half years living in an air raid shelter and have now been rehoused by the authorities in a village outside Cologne. Moe once received a medal from the Nazis for having more than ten children (large Aryan families being seen as the Nazi ideal), but now it seems that almost every member of that large family is embroiled in trouble of some sort and it’s anything but a happy, harmonious household.

Seventeen-year-old Katie is raising her young son alone after his father, a Belgian soldier, left her and went back to his own country. She sees the little boy as a burden preventing her from getting a job like her siblings and is envious of her older sister, Anna, whose own illegitimate child died. She can’t rely on her mother to help her with childcare because Moe is too distracted these days – she’s having an affair with their lodger, the much younger Rudi, and the whole family knows about it, including Joseph. And so, determined to have some fun and the chance to make some money, Katie has started sneaking out at night with several of her brothers to join a gang of other young people who engage in theft and violence under the cover of darkness.

Katie’s foster sister, Krista, has no memory of her own parents or her early life, having been found unconscious by Joseph during an air raid on Cologne. She has grown up with Joseph and Moe’s children, but is still seen as different and not quite like the others. Krista is in love with Paul, an American soldier, but is afraid to take their relationship any further because she knows her foster father doesn’t approve. Paul is confused. Is it his nationality that’s the problem – or is it because Joseph’s own feelings for Krista are not purely paternal?

I wasn’t prepared for this book being so dark! As well as the affairs, the unwanted pregnancies and the gang violence, some of the siblings also become implicated in a murder, while another, little Carola, is suffering from polio in hospital. It’s very bleak and the only characters I really liked, apart from the very young children, were Krista and Paul. Katie, her brother Hank, and the gang leader Leo were particularly horrible! The narrative moves around from one character to another so we have a chance to get to know all of the major players and I found Joseph, the patriarch of the family, the most complex and interesting. It’s clear that the war – and the time he spent in a prisoner of war camp in France – has affected him deeply, as has the loss of pride he has suffered in not being able to house his own family and the discovery that his children are now earning more than he is himself.

This is certainly not the usual gentle, comforting read I’ve come to associate with the Dean Street Press Furrowed Middlebrow imprint. I found it quite disturbing at times, though also very gripping. It’s a novel with a lot of depth and multiple layers and I know I’ve barely scratched the surface of it here. I can find very few other reviews of it, so if you’ve read it I would love to hear what you thought!

This edition of the book also contains a short story, The Russian for Sardines, originally published in the London Evening Standard in 1956 and also set in Germany after the war – a much more optimistic and uplifting story than A House on the Rhine! I’ll look forward to reading Frances Faviell’s other two novels published by DSP, Thalia and The Fledgeling, as well as her other memoir, The Dancing Bear.

Mischief by Charlotte Armstrong

6 Comments

I read this last month and it would have been perfect for Novellas in November, but I’ve been behind with my reviews. At 170 pages, this was a quick read but also quite an intense one. It was first published in 1950 and adapted for film two years later under the title Don’t Bother To Knock, starring Marilyn Monroe in the role of Nell. I haven’t seen it so don’t know how the plot and characters differ between page and screen.

Mischief begins with Peter and Ruth Jones in their New York hotel room preparing to leave for a convention where Peter will be giving an important speech. Unfortunately, they’ve been let down by their babysitter for the evening and urgently need a replacement. The hotel elevator operator, Eddie, comes to the rescue, volunteering the services of his niece, Nell, and assuring them that nine-year-old Bunny will be safe in her care. When Nell is brought up to their room, Ruth finds that there’s something about the young woman that makes her feel uneasy, but she can’t put her finger on what it is. Anyway, she tells herself that it’s only for one evening and Bunny will be going to bed soon, so what could possibly go wrong?

Meanwhile, Jed Towers is enjoying a night out with his girlfriend, Lyn – until a difference of opinion over giving money to a homeless person blows up into a huge argument and Jed goes back to his hotel room alone. Looking into a window on the other side of a courtyard he sees Nell, who catches his eye and invites him up for a drink. Still angry with Lyn, Jed accepts the invitation in the hope that he can still have some fun despite what has happened. However, he gets much more than he bargained for as his evening quickly goes from bad to worse.

I don’t want to say too much about what takes place inside Room 807 that night, but you won’t be surprised to hear that Ruth’s misgivings about the babysitter are proved correct. Nell is a terrifyingly psychopathic character, cold and heartless, seemingly lacking normal human emotions and empathy. Once in the room with her, Jed becomes increasingly uncomfortable, particularly when he becomes aware of Bunny’s presence in the adjoining bedroom. He wants to get himself out of the situation he has found himself in, but senses that Nell shouldn’t be left alone with the child. It seems to him that the problem with Nell is that she lives entirely in the present, not thinking about the consequences of her actions:

“What if the restraint of the future didn’t exist? What if you never said to yourself, ‘I’d better not. I’ll be in trouble if I do’? You’d be wild, all right. Capricious, unpredictable…absolutely wild.”

The tension builds throughout the book as one thing spirals into another and various hotel guests and staff members gradually become concerned about what is going on. I was genuinely worried for Bunny, especially as everyone seemed content to stand around talking about what might be happening in Room 807 and frustratingly slow to actually come and investigate!

As an example of mid 20th century American noir, I think this compares well to books I’ve read by Dorothy B. Hughes and Patricia Highsmith. I would like to read more of Charlotte Armstrong’s books and it seems she was quite prolific, so there are plenty to choose from.

Historical Musings #88: Books to look out for in 2025

29 Comments

In what has become a December tradition here on the blog, it’s time to look ahead to the historical fiction being published in the year to come. I’m listing below a selection of 2025 releases that have caught my attention for one reason or another – some are review copies I’ve received, some are new books by authors I’ve previously enjoyed and others just sound interesting. 2025 looks like being a great year for historical fiction – this list is longer than ever – and I hope there’s something here that appeals to you.

Dates provided are for the UK and were correct at the time of posting.

JANUARY

The Ghosts of Rome by Joseph O’Connor (30th January 2025) – The sequel to O’Connor’s My Father’s House, continuing the story of the Escape Line, a group of activists who smuggle refugees out of Nazi-occupied Rome.

The Queen of Fives by Alex Hay (30th January 2025) I’ve read this one already and will post my review when the book is published. It’s about a Victorian con woman who has five days to win a fortune.

Island Song by Pepsi Demacque-Crockett (30th January 2025) – This debut novel takes Agnes Deterville from the Caribbean island of St. Lucia to a new life in 1950s London.

The Resurrectionist by A. Rae Dunlap (30th January 2025) – Follows the story of a young medical student who joins a group of body snatchers, providing corpses to anatomy schools in 19th century Edinburgh.

FEBRUARY

The Night of the Scourge by Lars Mytting (4th February 2025) – This will be the final book in the Sister Bells trilogy set in a Norwegian village and based around the legend of two very special church bells.

The Secrets of the Rose by Nicola Cornick (7th February 2025) – Like most of Cornick’s novels, this is a dual time period one, with the historical storyline being set at Bamburgh Hall in 1715.

The Sirens by Emilia Hart (13th February 2025) – Divided between the 19th century and the present day, this is the story of two sets of sisters separated by two hundred years.

The Woman in the Wallpaper by Lora Jones (20th February 2025) – The story of two sisters who work at a French wallpaper factory during the Revolution.

The Lost Passenger by Frances Quinn (27th February 2025) I loved Frances Quinn’s last book, That Bonesetter Woman, so I’m looking forward to this one about a woman who disappears after the sinking of the Titanic.

Carrion Crow by Heather Parry (27th February 2025) – A Gothic novel about a woman locked in the attic of her family home. I’ve read this one in advance and it’s very unsettling!

The Portrait Artist by Dani Heywood-Lonsdale (27th February 2025) – Historical mystery with an art theme, set in the Victorian period.

The Queen and the Countess by Anne O’Brien (27th February 2025) – Set during the Wars of the Roses, one of my favourite time periods, this novel will tell the stories of Margaret of Anjou and Anne, Countess of Warwick.

MARCH

Murder at Gulls Nest by Jess Kidd (11th March 2025) – I’ve enjoyed everything I’ve read by Jess Kidd so far, but this sounds like something different from her – the first in a series of 1950s seaside mysteries.

The Paris Express by Emma Donoghue (20th March 2025) – Donoghue’s new novel is inspired by the Granville to Paris rail disaster of 1895.

APRIL

The Versailles Formula by Nancy Bilyeau (1st April 2025) – I’m not sure about the date for this one as I can’t find details anywhere except Goodreads, but this will be the next book in Bilyeau’s wonderful Genevieve Planché series.

The Eights by Joanna Miller (3rd April 2025) – A novel about the first group of female students to attend Oxford University.

The Greek House by Dinah Jefferies (24th April 2025) – A woman returns to Corfu in 1934, the site of her brother’s tragic disappearance years earlier.

The Midnight Carousel by Fiza Saeed McLynn (24th April 2025) – I’m intrigued by the sound of this novel about a French carousel-maker and a woman who discovers one of his carousels twenty years later.

MAY

Cleopatra by Natasha Solomons (8th May 2025) – I’ve enjoyed some of Solomons’ other books, so will be interested to see what she does with the story of Cleopatra.

The Cardinal by Alison Weir (22nd May 2025) – Following her recent Tudor Rose trilogy, Weir stays in the Tudor period for her new novel which covers the rise and fall of Cardinal Wolsey.

The House of Seymour by Joanna Hickson (22nd May 2025) – I’ve enjoyed most of Joanna Hickson’s other books. Her new one is about the Seymour family of Wolf Hall.

The Elopement by Gill Hornby (22nd May 2025) – In this sequel to Hornby’s Godmersham Park, Jane Austen’s niece, Fanny Knight, is now married to Sir Edward Knatchbull and busy raising his five children.

The Mourning Necklace by Kate Foster (29th May 2025) – Inspired by the real-life story of a woman who survived her own hanging in 1724.

JUNE

A Schooling in Murder by Andrew Taylor (5th June 2025) – After writing six books in the Marwood and Lovett series, Taylor is moving on to something different with this new historical mystery set in 1945.

The Rush by Beth Lewis (12th June 2025) – A new historical crime novel set in Canada during the Gold Rush.

Before Dorothy by Hazel Gaynor (19th June 2025) – Set in 1930s Kansas, this is the story of Emily Gale, Dorothy’s Aunt Em from The Wizard of Oz.

Love, Sex and Frankenstein by Caroline Lea (26th June 2025) – I’ve read several novels about the summer of 1816 at Lake Geneva when Mary Shelley began to write Frankenstein. It will be interesting to see how Lea approaches the subject.

JULY

Sinners by Elizabeth Fremantle (3rd July 2025) – Set in Rome in 1599, this novel is based on the true story of the Italian noblewoman, Beatrice Cenci.

The Art of a Lie by Laura Shepherd-Robinson (10th July 2025) – I’ve loved all of Shepherd-Robinson’s previous books and this new one, a thriller set in Georgian London, sounds equally wonderful!

The House at Devil’s Neck by Tom Mead (15th July 2025) – This will be the fourth book in Mead’s mystery series set in the 1930s and featuring the partnership of Scotland Yard detective Inspector Flint and the retired magician, Joseph Spector.

Love and Other Poisons by Lesley McDowell (17th July 2025) – Based on a true crime in which a woman, Madeleine Smith, is accused of murdering her lover in Victorian Glasgow.

A Case of Life and Limb by Sally Smith (17th July 2025) – The second in Smith’s new series about Gabriel Ward, a lawyer who works in London’s Inner Temple in the early 20th century. I loved the first book, so am particularly looking forward to this one!

How to Lose a Lord in Ten Days by Sophie Irwin (31st July 2025) – Irwin has written two very entertaining Regency romances and I’m sure this one will be just as much fun.

The Death of Shame by Ambrose Parry (31st July 2025) – I love this series set in the medical world of 19th century Edinburgh, so I’m happy to see there’s a new book coming next year.

AUGUST

Boudicca’s Daughter by Elodie Harper (28th August 2025) – Following her success with the Wolf Den trilogy, Harper’s next book is going to tell the story of Solina, Boudicca’s daughter.

SEPTEMBER

Circle of Days by Ken Follett (23rd September 2025) – Follett’s new novel will follow the stories of several people involved in the building of Stonehenge.

OCTOBER

House of Splinters by Laura Purcell (9th October 2025) – A new haunted house novel returning to the setting of Purcell’s earlier book, The Silent Companions.

Boleyn Traitor by Philippa Gregory (9th October 2025) – Gregory returns to the Tudor period for her new book about Jane Parker, wife of Anne Boleyn’s brother George.

The Witching Hour by various authors (16th October 2025) – I enjoyed The Winter Spirits so am looking forward to this new, similar collection of short stories by some of my favourite current authors of historical fiction.

~

Are you interested in reading any of these? Are there any other historical novels coming in 2025 that I’ve missed?