I can’t remember where or when I first heard about this book, but I’ve been interested in reading it for a long time and was pleased to see that it had been made available through NetGalley. It was worth the wait because it was every bit as much fun to read as I had thought and hoped it would be.
The novel opens with poet Richard Cadogan on his way to Oxford, where he hopes to find some literary inspiration. Arriving in the city just before midnight, he is surprised to find a shop with the door unlocked and goes inside to investigate. Inside he finds nothing but toys – ‘Meccano sets, engines, dolls and dolls’ houses, painted bricks, and lead soldiers’ – but venturing up the stairs at the back of the shop, he stumbles across the dead body of an elderly woman on the floor.
Before Cadogan can react, someone hits him on the head and he wakes up to find himself locked in a tiny room used for storing cleaning products. He manages to escape through a window and wastes no time in informing the police – but when they accompany him to the street the next morning, the toyshop is gone and in its place is a grocer’s which looks as though it has been there all the time. How could a shop possibly disappear overnight? Feeling that the police aren’t taking him seriously, Cadogan calls on his friend, Professor of English Language and Literature at Oxford University, Gervase Fen. Fen has some experience of solving mysteries (there are two previous novels in this series, which I haven’t read – The Case of the Gilded Fly and Holy Disorders) and he agrees to help Cadogan investigate.
With the main characters being a poet and an English professor, the dialogue between them is clever and witty, filled with literary allusions and wordplay. When they need a break from crime solving, they amuse themselves by playing games with titles such as Detestable Characters in Fiction. I’m sure we can all think of plenty of those!
“Got you!” said Fen triumphantly. “You miss your turn. Those vulgar little man-hunting minxes in Pride and Prejudice.”
At this exultant shout the muffled, rabbity man at the nearby table frowned, got unsteadily to his feet, and came over to them.
“Sir,” he said, interrupting Cadogan’s offering of Richard Feverel, “surely I did not hear you speaking disrespectfully of the immortal Jane?”
But the literary references are not always just for fun…they form an important part of the plot too. As a mystery involving wills, inheritances, unscrupulous lawyers and small spotted dogs begins to unfold, Fen and Cadogan discover that a knowledge of Edward Lear’s limericks will be useful in deciphering some of the clues. I loved this aspect of the novel; it was so imaginative and made up for the fact that the mystery itself is not a particularly strong one. The plot relies heavily on coincidences, improbabilities and things which are so far-fetched as to be ridiculous – but none of that really mattered to me. I was left with the impression that the author had as much fun writing this book as I had reading it.
Published in 1946, The Moving Toyshop is the third of Edmund Crispin’s Gervase Fen novels but it stands alone perfectly and I didn’t feel that I was at any disadvantage because of not having read the first two books. I’m sure I’ll be tempted to pick up one of the other books in the series soon!
She Reads Novels 
I love the quote! I, too, like literary mysteries, and this one sounds right up my alley.
I would have liked to have quoted the entire Detestable Characters game – I loved it! If you enjoy literary mysteries I would highly recommend this one.
Crispin’s books are just wonderful (I’ve read the lot) and I think Fen is one of my favourite detectives ever. I tend to find myself frequently laughing out loud. This might well be his best, but they’re all worth reading!
I’m glad to hear that – I’m sure I’ll be reading some of the others!
This sounds like a lot of fun. I’ve heard the name Gervase Fen, but haven’t read any of the books. Must look out for them!
I think you might enjoy this one. Definitely worth looking out for!
Thank you for writing this. I love Crispen. It’s hard to select a favourite, but I think that “The Moving Toyship” is my life-time favourite mystery novel.
I’m glad to hear this is one of your favourites. I loved it and am looking forward to reading more of the Gervase Fen novels.
This sounds fun and a good mystery for Autumn and the RIP event 🙂
It’s a great choice for RIP if you want a murder mystery that’s fun to read without being scary or graphic at all. 🙂
I’ve read the Gilded Fly story but never got round to writing a review. As I’ve got this title sitting on my shelves (not far from Angela Carter’s The Magic Toyshop as it happens!) I’m encouraged to try that soon, despite noting your caveat that the mystery itself may be “not a particularly strong one.” That was certainly the case with the Gilded Fly tale.
As a mystery it was too implausible to take seriously, but the characters, the humour and the literary references more than made up for it!
This sounds like a fun but intriguing read. One to look out for.
I’ve read better mysteries, but none that were as much fun as this one. It’s definitely one to look out for!
I have heard a lot about this book, too, and would like to read it sometime.