Fireside Gothic by Andrew Taylor

fireside-gothic Having read and enjoyed some of Andrew Taylor’s historical crime novels, I was immediately intrigued when I heard about Fireside Gothic, a hardback collection of three novellas which had originally been published separately in ebook form as ‘Kindle Singles’.  The stories are all quite different but, as Taylor says in his author’s note, they do share some common themes.

Broken Voices, the first of the three, has the feel of a classic Christmas ghost story. Set in an English cathedral city just before the First World War, it follows the adventures of two schoolboys whose circumstances mean they have to stay at school in the care of a retired teacher over the Christmas holidays. After listening to the teacher’s tales of mysterious happenings in the nearby cathedral, one of the boys begins to hear ghostly music and persuades his friend to sneak into the cathedral with him late one night to investigate.

Broken Voices gets the collection off to a good start.  Although I would describe it as an eerie story rather than a scary one, with its haunting atmosphere, winter setting and vivid descriptions of the deserted cathedral, this is the most obviously ‘gothic’ of the stories in the book.

The second story, The Leper House, is my favourite. Set in the modern day this time, our narrator is driving home from his sister’s funeral when his car breaks down on a lonely country road near the Suffolk coast. Setting off through the rain and wind in search of help, he manages to find shelter for the night and during his stay he has a brief but unforgettable encounter with a woman who lives in a neighbouring cottage. In the morning, he discovers that both the woman and the cottage have disappeared – and becomes obsessed with finding an explanation for his strange experience.

I can’t say too much, but the story then goes in a direction which was completely unexpected and which I loved. It raises a lot of fascinating questions and some of them are still unanswered at the end. There are some ideas here which I would have liked to have seen developed further; this story has all the ingredients of a full-length novel and I was sorry it had to come to an end so soon!

The collection finishes with The Scratch, another contemporary story. Unlike the first two, this one is narrated by a woman. Her name is Clare and she lives in the Forest of Dean with her husband, Gerald, and their pet cat. At the beginning of the story, their orphaned nephew, Jack, comes to stay with them on his return from fighting in Afghanistan. Jack’s time in the army has left him with a fear of cats, a dislike of enclosed spaces and a scratch on his arm which won’t seem to heal.

This is an interesting story, but the focus is mainly on the complicated relationships between Clare, Gerald and Jack, so the supernatural elements are much more subtle than in the other novellas. This is my least favourite of the three, although there are some clever little twists at the end which took me by surprise!

Fireside Gothic is an entertaining and unusual collection. The title and cover had led me to expect something slightly different – something spookier and, well, more gothic – but I did still enjoy these three novellas, particularly the middle one.  While it’s still winter, this would be an ideal time to get yourself a copy of this book and spend a cold, dark evening reading it by the fire.

Thanks to HarperCollins for providing a review copy of Fireside Gothic.

13 thoughts on “Fireside Gothic by Andrew Taylor

  1. FictionFan says:

    Sounds great! I do like this more gentle sounding spooky stuff than all out horror. I actually find it much more effective at tingling my spine. Must look out for this one…

    • Helen says:

      I like the gentle type of ghost story too, so I did enjoy this book even though it wasn’t quite what I’d expected. There are definitely a few spine-tingling moments!

    • Helen says:

      I think you might enjoy these stories. This book could be a good way to get a taste of Andrew Taylor’s writing without committing to one of his longer novels.

  2. Pam Thomas says:

    I’ve recently discovered Andrew Taylor – I’ve read ‘The Scent of Death’ and its sequel ‘The Silent Boy’, set in the late 18th century (the first in Revolutionary America, the second partly in Revolutionary France), both of which I really enjoyed. He has a very easy writing style, but that’s not to say his books are ‘cosy’ – far from it. You also feel that he’s really done his research, though he never bludgeons you over the head with it, and his characters are well-rounded and often very likeable. Thoroughly recommended. I think I’ll try these next, though I’ve also been recommended ‘The American Boy’, which is about Edgar Allen Poe.

    • Helen says:

      I love Andrew Taylor’s writing for all the reasons you’ve stated here. The American Boy is my favourite of his books – Poe has a smaller role than I’d expected, but it’s wonderful anyway and I would definitely recommend it. I enjoyed the two Edward Savill books you’ve mentioned too, and also The Anatomy of Ghosts (set in 18th century London and Cambridge) and The Ashes of London (set in 1666).

Please leave a comment. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.