In this, the seventh book in Alan Bradley’s Flavia de Luce series, our twelve-year-old detective is sent away to boarding school in 1950s Canada, having been banished from her family home at the end of the previous novel. If you have never read a Flavia mystery before, this is probably not the best place to start; I would recommend reading at least a few of the earlier ones first, particularly the sixth, The Dead in Their Vaulted Arches, so that you will understand the reasons for her banishment and the choice of this particular Canadian school.
Anyway, back to As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust. Almost as soon as Flavia arrives at Miss Bodycote’s Female Academy in Toronto, she stumbles upon yet another dead body – or rather, this one stumbles upon Flavia when it falls down the chimney in her room, having been dislodged by another girl who has climbed up to hide from a teacher. Why is there a dead body up the chimney? Who is it? Could it be one of the three missing girls who have all disappeared from the Academy over the last year or two? Flavia doesn’t know, but she’s determined to find out!
This is the first book in the series not to be set at Buckshaw, the de Luce ancestral home in the English village of Bishop’s Lacey. I have always found the setting to be part of the charm of these books, so although it was nice to have a change, I did find myself missing Father, Feely, Daffy, Dogger and everyone else from Buckshaw. There are plenty of new characters in this book to take their places – including an enigmatic and intimidating headmistress and a chemistry teacher who has been on trial for murder – but none of them felt as well drawn as the characters in the previous novels.
Still, I always enjoy a school setting because it brings back memories of the school stories I loved as a child, such as Enid Blyton’s Malory Towers and St Clare’s books. Maybe Alan Bradley liked that sort of story too and wanted an opportunity to write one of his own; otherwise I’m not sure I really see the point in moving Flavia out of her usual setting. I had expected the storyline involving the Nide, which was introduced in the last book, to be advanced in this one, but actually we learn very little more about it – and what we do learn just made me more confused!
I was pleased to find that this book had a much stronger mystery element than the previous one and although some parts of the mystery didn’t feel fully resolved at the end, it was nice to see Flavia back to making her lists of suspects and searching for clues. Finally, don’t Alan Bradley’s books have great titles? This one is taken from Shakespeare’s Cymbeline: “Golden lads and girls all must, As chimney-sweepers, come to dust”. The title of the next one, Thrice the Brinded Cat Hath Mew’d, is also Shakespeare-inspired. I’m looking forward to reading it – despite not liking the last two books as much as the earlier ones, I do still enjoy spending time with Flavia!
This is Book #2 for my R.I.P. XII challenge.
11 thoughts on “As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust by Alan Bradley”
I didn’t enjoy this one quite as much as the previous books, I missed the sisterly sniping apart from anything else, if I’m remembering correctly.
Yes, I really missed Daffy and Feely! They played such a big part in the other books, it wasn’t the same without them.
I enjoyed the first one in the series but found the overall conceit began to pall after that. I’m glad other people are still getting something out of them though.
I’ve found the series to be quite uneven, but in general I think the earlier ones were better.
I wasn’t so sure I liked the espionage angle in the last few. She returns home in the next one, though.
I think these books were good enough without the espionage element. I’m glad she’s going home in the next book.
Yeah, although I have to say that the sprightly tone goes away in the next one, if I remember correctly.
I have absolutely loved all of them. The last is on my reserve list at the library, so thanks for the reminder to check for his latest!
I’m glad you’ve loved them all, Claudia. I think some of the books are better than others, but I am still enjoying the series overall.
While I was reading your review, I was thinking that this book could be part of that R.I.P. Challenge, and then I realized that indeed it was. Sorry you didn’t like it as much as the previous ones, but it sounds, from the comments above, that Flavia returns to her old setting, so maybe there is still hope for this series.
The Flavia books are perfect for the R.I.P. challenge! I’m pleased she’s returning to her usual setting in the next book – I do like school stories, but I missed Flavia’s family and friends in this one.