This is the first book I’ve read by Sarah Moss, an author I had never really thought about trying until I saw so much praise for her latest novel, Ghost Wall, last year. Bodies of Light is apparently loosely linked to an earlier book, Night Waking, but I didn’t feel that I’d missed anything by reading this one first.
The setting for Bodies of Light is Victorian Manchester where, as the novel opens, a newly married couple – Elizabeth and Alfred Moberley – are moving into their new home. Even this early in their marriage, there are clues that suggest they might not be very happy together; Alfred is a painter who appreciates the finer things in life while Elizabeth is passionate about social reform and women’s rights. Their two daughters, Alethea (Ally) and May, grow up trying to please both parents, being asked to model for their father’s latest portrait one day and accompanying their mother on one of her missions to help women in Manchester’s poorest areas the next.
I really enjoyed the first half of this book; after a slow start I found that I had become completely drawn into the lives of the Moberley family. Each chapter starts with a description of a portrait painted by Alfred or one of his circle, giving an idea of what will follow in the pages to come, and I thought that was a nice touch. As the novel progresses and the children grow older, we see that Elizabeth, despite her good deeds in public, can be a harsh and unloving mother; to explain this, Sarah Moss spends some time at the beginning of the book showing us what made her the way she is, focusing on Elizabeth’s relationship with her own mother and the depression she suffered after Ally’s birth.
The second half of the novel is devoted mainly to Ally, as she goes to London to study medicine at the first medical school to accept female students. She is pushed into this career path by her mother, who believes very strongly that women – particularly ‘fallen women’ – should be entitled to request treatment from a female doctor and who likes the idea of her own daughter becoming one of these doctors. Ally is an intelligent young woman who loves learning, so she throws herself into her studies, but there is always a sense that she is doing this mainly to make her mother happy – and yet, whatever she does, it seems that Elizabeth is never happy.
I felt so sorry for Ally, who self-harms and suffers from nightmares as she is growing up, longing for some comfort and compassion from her mother but receiving only criticism and impatience instead, told that she has no right to complain about anything ‘because there is always someone else worse off.’ Interestingly, her younger sister May, who has the same upbringing, doesn’t seem to suffer from Ally’s anxiety-related problems, possibly due to the fact that Ally, as the eldest, has always felt under more pressure.
Once Ally had left home to begin her medical studies, I found the story a bit less compelling but still interesting. It certainly made me appreciate the educational opportunities that are open to women today and how difficult it must have been for those who were among the first to try to enter a field dominated by men. This is a fascinating book and I do like Sarah Moss’s writing, so I now want to read the sequel, Signs for Lost Children, as well as the earlier Night Waking, which I think tells some more of May’s story.
13 thoughts on “Bodies of Light by Sarah Moss”
You have found a new author! That is always a happy thing.
Yes, it’s good to know I have the rest of her books to look forward to now. 🙂
Like you, Helen, I have seen Sarah Moss’s name everywhere in the book world over the last couple of years but not yet got round to reading her. I think I shall suggest one of her books for a book group as it sounds as though she is exploring really interesting ideas that would provoke a lot of discussion.
I think this book would be ideal for a book group discussion as it does explore a lot of interesting issues, but I expect her others will be equally thought-provoking. I’m looking forward to trying more of them.
With those titles, I thought maybe there would be ghosts!
They do sound like ghost stories, but this one certainly wasn’t!
Signs For Lost Children is great – it follows Ally, not May, but it takes up many of the issues raised in Bodies of Light, especially about the psychological persistence of a harsh upbringing. I recommend it to virtually everyone.
It sounds great. I’ll probably try to read that one next. 🙂
Like you, I have read one book – Cold Earth, the author’s first – and want to read more. I love the sound of this.
Cold Earth does sound interesting, although I’ll probably read the sequel to this one first. I loved Sarah Moss’s writing.
I read Signs for Lost Children without knowing it was the last in the series of three. I adored it for so many reasons; it remains my standout read of 2018 and at Christmas I asked for (and received) all three books as I can’t imagine not loving the first two. I can’t understand why Sarah Moss isn’t more widely known; I think her writing is wonderful.
I agree – she deserves to be much better known. I hope you enjoy the other two books you received for Christmas. 🙂