This week Ali is hosting a Daphne du Maurier Reading Week and as du Maurier is one of my favourite authors, I thought this would be a perfect opportunity to read one of the few remaining books of hers that I still haven’t read. As I’ve enjoyed some of du Maurier’s short story collections in the past, I decided to read The Doll, her book of ‘lost short stories’, most of which were written very early in her writing career (mainly between 1926 and 1932) but not published until more recently. My expectations for this book weren’t too high as I thought there might be a reason why these particular stories had been forgotten for so long, but actually I was pleasantly surprised by it. Although some of the stories in the collection feel too short and incomplete, there are some great ones amongst them too.
As is often the case when you read an author’s early work, it’s possible to see the seeds of du Maurier’s later work being planted and future themes and ideas being experimented with. The title story, The Doll, written when the author was twenty years old, follows a man who falls in love with a violinist by the name of Rebecca. As his love turns into obsession, he discovers that he has a rival in the form of a life-sized doll called Julio. This is a dark and creepy story and the name of the character makes it difficult not to think of du Maurier’s most famous novel Rebecca (especially as there are some similarities between the two Rebeccas).
The Happy Valley also foreshadows Rebecca in some ways and involves a woman who has recurring dreams of a house in a place she calls the Happy Valley. With its ghostly undertones and supernatural twist, this was one of the stories that particularly impressed me. It also has the strong sense of place and beautiful descriptive writing I associate with du Maurier’s work, as does another of the stories – East Wind – in which the wind changes direction and blows a boat full of sailors ashore on a remote island. The arrival of the newcomers brings a great deal of excitement to the isolated island community, but temptation and evil have also come in with the tide and will leave their mark when the wind changes again.
It was almost as if there were no such place, as if the island were a dream, a phantom creation of a sailor’s brain, something rising out of the sea at midnight as a challenge to reality, then vanishing in surf and mist to be forgotten, to be half-consciously remembered years later, flickering for a bewildered second in a dusty brain as a dead thought. Yet to the people of St Hilda’s the island was reality, the ships that came and went were their phantoms.
Another story that stood out for me was Tame Cat, a disturbing tale of an innocent young girl referred to only as Baby who returns home from a long absence in France and is reunited with her mother and the man she calls Uncle John. Baby has always thought of Uncle John as being like a tame cat, but now that she is growing up and becoming a woman she finds that his position in the family is not quite as she’d always assumed.
Some of the topics that seem to come up again and again throughout this collection are young couples falling in and out of love and husbands and wives growing disillusioned with their marriages. Sometimes du Maurier treats this in a humorous way, such as in Frustration, where a newly married couple embark on their honeymoon and everything that can go wrong does go wrong, and Week-End, where another couple go away for the weekend believing themselves to be madly in love, but gradually discover that they don’t even like each other – something which comes as a relief when they realise they won’t have to speak to each other using ridiculous baby talk anymore! Other stories are more poignant; I loved Nothing Hurts for Long, a sad story about a woman preparing to welcome her husband home after three months in Germany. When a friend tells her about the disintegration of her own marriage, she is sympathetic but convinced that the same thing couldn’t possibly happen to her…
She went and stood before the looking-glass. Perhaps he would creep in suddenly and stand behind her, and put his hands on her shoulders, and lean his face against hers.
She closed her eyes. Darling! Was that a taxi? No – nothing. ‘This wasn’t how I imagined it at all,’ she thought.
There are thirteen stories in the collection so I’m not going to discuss all of them here, but there were only one or two that I didn’t like very much. The overall quality is not as good as some of the other du Maurier collections I’ve read, Don’t Look Now and Other Stories, The Birds and Other Stories or The Breaking Point: Short Stories, and I don’t think I would recommend this book as a starting point for readers who are new to du Maurier’s work, but if you’re already a fan I think you’ll find a lot to enjoy here.
17 thoughts on “The Doll: Short Stories by Daphne du Maurier”
These stories sound very good, especially that foreshadowing of Rebecca. Thanks for the review.
Yes, it was interesting to see how some of these short stories foreshadow her later work. I liked some of her other collections better but this one is great too.
I liked this short story collection of du Maurier. There were some really good stories in it. 🙂
I enjoyed almost all of the stories in this book. I’m glad you liked it too. 🙂
She’s so good at short stories – I prefer them to her novels, in fact. Haven’t come across this collection, though, so thanks for highlighting it. It’s always interesting to see how an author started out.
I prefer her novels, but I do love the short stories too (and I’m not usually much of a short story fan). I don’t think this is one of her best collections, but it’s definitely worth reading!
You conclude in a similar way to the conclusion I’m about to post on The Loving Spirit – her first novel: worth reading but not the best place to start if new to du Maurier’s work. For me though, since I have just read that early novel written at the same time as these stories were being written, I suspect this might be just the time to pick up this collection. Lovely review, Helen.
I liked The Loving Spirit, but it’s certainly not as strong as her later work, and the same applies to these short stories. It was interesting to see what her writing was like at the beginning of her career, though, and I think you would enjoy this collection.
I wonder if you would have enjoyed the stories as much if you had read them before reading some of her longer fiction, without the added joy of discovering some tidbits (like the early Rebecca). In any case, I do enjoy her short fiction and should read more.
I think they were enjoyable stories in their own right, but the fact that I could relate them to her later work did add an extra layer of interest.
I’ve just discovered her short stories and really enjoyed the Don’t Look Now collection. These sound equally interesting
The Don’t Look Now collection is wonderful – I’m glad you liked it! I don’t think the stories in this collection are quite as strong, but I still enjoyed them.
Although you didn’t love this as much as others, I am pleased you enjoyed it. You’ve reminded me I need to read of her short story collections.
Du Maurier wrote such great short stories! I’m sure you’ll enjoy her other collections too when you get to them.