I loved The Rose Code by Kate Quinn – it was one of my favourite books last year. Because of that, I think my expectations for her new novel, The Diamond Eye, were slightly too high. I enjoyed it, but I don’t think it will be one of my books of the year this time.
The Diamond Eye is the story of Lyudmila Pavlichenko, a female sniper in the Soviet Army during World War II (and a real historical figure). Lyudmila, or ‘Mila’ as she is called in the novel, was born in Ukraine but considered herself Russian. The book was written before the current war in Ukraine began earlier this year, which gives something as simple as Mila’s choice of identity new relevance.
When we first meet Mila, she is a twenty-one-year-old history student in Kiev (now known as Kyiv, of course) and is trying to get a divorce from her husband Alexei, who seduced her as a teenager then left her to raise their son, Slavka, alone. After an encounter with Alexei at a shooting range during which Mila embarrasses herself by missing a shot, she decides to join an advanced marksmanship course so that she’ll never miss again and can prove to Slavka that she’s the equal of his father. This decision changes Mila’s life because, when Hitler invades Russia a few years later, she is handed a rifle and enlisted into the Red Army as a sniper.
We then follow two alternating storylines – one which describes Mila’s time in the army and how she acquires her reputation as ‘Lady Death’, being credited with 309 kills, and another set in 1942 as Mila embarks on a US tour in an attempt to persuade the Allies to provide support for Russia against the Nazis. The chapters set in America explore Mila’s relationship with Eleanor Roosevelt and a fictitious plot to assassinate the President. This invented storyline adds some tension and excitement to the book, but with Mila’s own life being so fascinating I’m not sure that it was really necessary!
The factual parts of the novel are based on Lyudmila Pavlichenko’s own memoir, Lady Death: The Memoirs of Stalin’s Sniper, which I haven’t read. In fact, I knew nothing at all about Mila before reading this book so everything in it was new to me. Quinn includes a very comprehensive author’s note at the end in which she explains where she tried to stick to the known facts and where she had used her imagination to fill in gaps or make the story more interesting (mainly the bits concerning Mila’s marriage to Alexei and her romantic relationships with two men she meets in the army). Some of the most surprising parts of the story, such as Mila’s friendship with the First Lady are actually true.
There’s a lot of focus on military life, weapons and tactics, which I suppose is to be expected in a novel about a sniper, but that’s never been a particular area of interest to me and reading about the Bletchley Park codebreakers in The Rose Code was much more to my taste. Still, it’s always good to learn something new and I did enjoy the parts of the book about Mila’s personal life and ambassadorial work, if not so much the parts about shooting and killing. I’m sure I’ll be reading more of Kate Quinn’s books.
Thanks to HarperCollins for providing a copy of this book for review via NetGalley.
This is book 28/50 read for the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge 2022.
11 thoughts on “The Diamond Eye by Kate Quinn”
I *thought* the name rang a bell. I have her biography ‘Lady Death’ (inevitably unread), plus ‘Avenging Angels – Soviet Women Snipers on the Eastern Front 1941-45 by Lyuba Vinogradova (unread) and ‘The Unwomanly Face of War’ by Svetlana Alexievich (also unread).
This sounds like something I’d *definitely* enjoy. Thanks!
Yes, I think you would enjoy this book! It would be interesting to read both this one and the Lady Death biography to see how the facts compare with the fiction.
I think I’d like The Rose Code more than this one, too. Although her life as a sniper does sound interesting. And if her friendship with Eleanor Roosevelt hadn’t really happened I’d be shaking my head in disbelief. 😀
It seems an unusual friendship, but it did really happen and there are pictures of the two of them together!
I can see where some of the weaponry stuff might have felt tedious, but I didn’t mind it at all. I adored this, but I also loved The Rose Code and The Huntress. I also read her book The Alice Network, which was really good, but I liked these three better.
Yes, I remember reading your review of this one. Maybe I’ll try The Huntress next.
The military stuff wouldn’t appeal to me much either, but it still sounds a rather interesting read. The Rose Code is one I see myself enjoying very much on the other hand.
I found The Rose Code much more enjoyable – I loved reading about Bletchley Park and the work of the WWII codebreakers.
That’s one of the reasons I enjoyed reading Robert Harris’ Enigma.
I loved The Rose Code so much so my expectations are way high for this book!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts with the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge!
I hope you enjoy it! I did like it, but definitely preferred The Rose Code.