The Sun Walks Down by Australian author Fiona McFarlane is not a book I had considered reading until it appeared on this year’s shortlist for the Walter Scott Prize for Historical Fiction. Attempting to read all the shortlisted books for the prize is one of my ongoing personal projects and this is the third I’ve read so far from this year’s list (the others are Act of Oblivion and These Days).
The novel is set in South Australia and takes place over a period of seven days in September 1883. On the first day, a dust storm sweeps through the small town of Fairly in the Flinders Ranges and after it has passed, six-year-old Denny Wallace is found to have gone missing. As the whole community becomes caught up in the search for him, McFarlane introduces us to each resident of the town in turn, exploring their lives and the ways in which they are touched by Denny’s disappearance.
As well as Denny’s parents and siblings, we also meet a Pashtun cameleer, a Ramindjeri tracker, a Swedish painter and his English wife, a pair of newlyweds and an assortment of farmworkers and housemaids. Each has their own story to be told and some are given their own chapter, written in the form of a dream, a confession, a prayer or a set of notes. In this way, McFarlane looks at various aspects of life in colonial Australia and the relationships between the Indigenous people and the European newcomers. Although I did find this interesting (I’ve read shamefully little about 19th century Australia) I felt that there were too many characters in the book and the viewpoint changed from one to another too quickly, preventing me from forming a strong connection with any of them. I would also have preferred a tighter focus on the search for Denny as this seemed to get pushed aside for long periods.
I did love the beautiful descriptions of the Flinders Ranges and the way McFarlane uses colours to bring to life images of the sun, sky and clouds. 1883 was the year when Krakatoa erupted and caused a ‘volcanic winter’ with unusually vivid sunsets:
The sky burns and leaps, it gilds and candles – every drenched inch of it, until the sun falls below the ranges. Then the sky darkens. The red returns, stealthy now, with green above and lilac higher still. It deepens into purple. Here’s the strange new cloud, hovering in its own grey light. Then night comes in, black and blue and grey and white, and the moon in its green bag swings heavy over the red nation of the ranges.
I think I would describe The Sun Walks Down as a book that I admired rather than one that I particularly enjoyed. I can see why other people have given it glowing reviews and why it’s being nominated for awards, but it just wasn’t for me. That probably means it will win the Walter Scott Prize this year – not long until we find out!
This is book 20/50 read for the 2023 Historical Fiction Reading Challenge.
12 thoughts on “The Sun Walks Down by Fiona McFarlane”
Coincidentally, I’m currently reading this! I’m only on about page 95, but I’ve already come to similar conclusions to you – too many characters, not differentiated enough, not enough focus on Denny (and he seems to need remarkably little water), but some of the writing is lovely. I may skim much of it, as there’s a queue for it at the library and it’s due back at the end of the week!
Not anonymous, it’s Pam Thomas – don’t know why that happened!
I hope you have time to finish it. I don’t think you’ll miss much if you have to skim, to be honest. It’s a beautifully written book but doesn’t have a lot of plot.
This one sounded interesting from our list, but I see what you mean. It will probably be a while before I am able to get ahold of this book, because the ones from Australia take the longest. In any case, I notice I also didn’t realize when you posted your review for These Days that that was on our list. I’ll post links from my site to yours today. (I think I already did Act of Oblivion, but if not I’ll do that, too.)
I hope you don’t have to wait too long for the Australian books this time and I hope you enjoy this one more than I did when you eventually get to read it! I’ll update your links on my list as soon as I have time – I think I’ve missed a few recent ones.
I definitely missed a bunch of yours. That goes from not being aware of the names of this year’s nominees.
Although I’m not usually a fan of books with lightly sketched characterizations, for me the portrayal of the community itself was so effective and strong, I really didn’t mind it in this book.
Yes, that’s a good point – the portrayal of the community as a whole is stronger than the individual characters. I wish I had enjoyed the book more overall, but I did love the setting!
Your review, and the remarks of other commenters means this is a book I’ll sample if it comes my way, but I shan’t expend energy looking for it.
I definitely think it’s worth trying if you come across it. It wasn’t for me, but lots of people have loved it!
I was surprised to see my library system owns this book and interested to read that the author did writing residencies in Massachusetts and New Hampshire. It sounds intriguing but maybe not rush-out-and-read-worthy (especially now that I have begun Middlemarch). I like the idea of reading all these historical fiction nominees but suspect most of them won’t be published in the US.
Sometimes the nominees aren’t all available in the UK for a while either, particularly the Australian ones, so I was pleased to be able to get hold of this book so quickly. I think it’s definitely worth reading, but not really a must-read.