My first introduction to Barbara Erskine’s work last year, River of Destiny, left me unimpressed but I was assured by Erskine fans that her earlier books were better, so when I found this one at the library I decided to give her another chance. I also thought it sounded like an ideal book to read for the RIP challenge, even though it wasn’t on my original list.
When author Kate Kennedy’s relationship with her boyfriend, Jon, comes to an end and she is forced to move out of their London home, she decides to rent a cottage on the Essex coast where she can spend the winter working on her new biography of Byron. The owners of the cottage, Diana and Roger Lindsey, live in a farmhouse nearby and do their best to make Kate feel welcome, but unfortunately not all the members of the Lindsey family are happy to see her. The eldest son, Greg, an aspiring artist, had been using the cottage for his painting and resents Kate for pushing him out. His fifteen-year-old sister, Alison, is an amateur archaeologist and is furious when she discovers that Kate has been interfering with her dig at what she believes is an ancient Roman grave.
When strange things start to happen at Redall Cottage, Kate suspects Greg and Alison of trying to frighten her away, but after several encounters with ghostly figures she begins to accept that she is being haunted by the ghosts of the Roman soldier Marcus Severus Secundus, his wife Claudia, and the Druid prince, Nion. It seems that Kate has stumbled upon a two thousand-year-old love triangle that ended in a murder and a curse – and secrets that have been buried under the earth for centuries are about to be revealed at last.
Midnight is a Lonely Place was much better than River of Destiny, but still not a book that I can say I loved. I was right about it being a perfect RIP choice, though. It has all the elements of a classic ghost story: a lonely, isolated cottage, an ancient burial site, ghostly apparitions, strange smells and unexplained noises, relentless snow, sleet and blizzards. It’s quite scary in places and you might not want to read it late at night if you’re on your own (while I was finishing the book on Friday evening the real-life weather outside obliged with heavy rain and strong winds which made it even more atmospheric).
While Marcus Severus Secundus, Claudia and Nion do have a strong presence in this novel, the story is set entirely in the early 1990s (which actually feels surprisingly dated from a 2013 perspective) and we only learn about the Roman characters’ lives in brief flashbacks at the start of the chapters. I would have liked their storyline to have been more fully developed as I felt I didn’t get to know them well enough to really care about them or their secrets and this meant that, for me, the novel wasn’t as effective as it would have been with a stronger historical element.
The second half of the book is suspenseful and action packed, as the level of paranormal activity increases and more and more of Kate’s friends and neighbours become involved (at one point it felt as if the whole population of Essex were wandering about getting lost in the snow) but I found the ending disappointingly abrupt. I’m not sure I correctly interpreted the final page and after reading what was quite a long book (more than 400 pages) I had expected a more satisfying conclusion. I certainly enjoyed this book a lot more than River of Destiny but I’m not sure I’ll be looking for any more of Barbara Erskine’s books – though I might still be interested in reading Lady of Hay, her first and best known book.
15 thoughts on “Midnight is a Lonely Place by Barbara Erskine”
I’m not sure I’d be suitably appreciative of all the paranormal activity, as you call it, but I must say the title of the book is pretty wonderful!
Yes, I love the title too! I didn’t expect the paranormal aspect of the book to be so strong, to be honest – it turned out to be much scarier than the other Erskine book I read!
I have this book and I am planning to read it soon. I read only another book by Barbara Erskine, Hiding from the light, and, while I found the first half of the book really engaging, the second part went too far for me… the plot and the characters went all over the place.
I am interested in reading Lady of Hay as well.
I hope you enjoy this one more than Hiding from the Light, Ludo.
Sorry this wasn’t a better read…although I do like the ghost story aspect of it. I’m always in search of a really good ghost story…but unfortunately most of them come up short.
I’m often disappointed by ghost stories too but this was quite a spooky one. I just wish the characters had been stronger and the ending was more satisfying.
Oh my gosh,I was going out of my mind trying to remember the name of this book a little while back. I can’t recall the ending right now, but I remember being pised off too! I also wanted more about the Romans, and about the little sister. Great review.
I was so disappointed by the ending! I had hoped everything would be tied up and explained at the end of the book, but instead I was left feeling even more confused.
I’ve only read Lady of Hay I think but remember being shocked at how dated it felt and how much all the ‘modern’ characters drank – I even suggested you could have a fun drinking game matching them and see how many chapters you could remain upright for… 😉
I don’t mind the paranormal angle but I do think she has a problem with resolving her love triangles and dramas.
You could have played that game with this book too…I particularly noticed the attitude of the characters towards drink driving – it made it feel very dated, even for a book written twenty years ago.
Your review about this book Has urged me to read it. Though I have never read any book of Barbara Erskine before, I might start now. Thanks 🙂
I hope you enjoy her books. 🙂
I read Lady of Hay back in 2001. It was my first and Ive been hooked on her books. But maybe thats just because I find this reincarnation theme really interesting. Do read Lady of Hay – its mesmerising. I actually had to shake myself a few times to get out from under its spell. Midnight is a lonely place is interesting; however I agree its not her best.
I’ve actually read Lady of Hay since I wrote this review – I loved the historical storyline, but the modern day one not so much. Last year I also read her latest novel, Sleeper’s Castle, and really enjoyed that one, so I’m glad I didn’t give up on Barbara Erskine!