Frog Music by Emma Donoghue

Frog Music This is the second book I’ve read by Emma Donoghue – the first was Room, which I enjoyed, and since then I’ve been wanting to try one of her historical fiction novels. This new one, Frog Music, is set in San Francisco in 1876 and is based on a true crime story.

Twenty-four-year-old Blanche Beunon, once a star of the Cirque d’Hiver in Paris, is now a dancer in a San Francisco burlesque club. She lives in the city’s Chinatown with her lover, Arthur Deneve, and his friend – and former partner on the flying trapeze – Ernest Girard. One week in August, two newcomers enter their little circle. One of these is P’tit, Blanche and Arthur’s baby boy, reunited with his parents after a year of separation. Blanche has rarely even thought about her baby during his absence, but now she discovers what being a mother really means.

The other new arrival is a woman called Jenny Bonnet, just released from jail after being arrested for the crime of dressing in men’s clothes. Jenny, who makes her living from catching frogs and selling them to French and Chinese restaurants, is like nobody else Blanche has ever met and makes her think differently about herself and her life. But when Jenny is shot dead, Blanche is convinced that she herself was the intended victim. Can she find the murderer before he kills again and before she loses P’tit again forever?

The real life murder case on which Frog Music is based remains an unsolved crime to this day, but the solution Donoghue provides is believable and consistent with what we have learned about the personalities and motives of the characters involved. The author also includes a detailed Afterword in which she explains which of the characters and events in the story are factual and which are purely fictional.

While there are some very unpleasant, unlikeable people in this novel, I thought the central character, Blanche, was wonderful. Her personality is a mass of contradictions: she’s tough yet vulnerable, intelligent yet naïve, self-absorbed yet sensitive. She’s such a well drawn character and felt completely real. I loved her and desperately wanted her to find some real happiness. Her story is so sad at times – I don’t want to say too much, but the circumstances surrounding the reappearance of P’tit are shocking and heartbreaking; I found that part of the book quite painful to read. As for Jenny, she remains a secretive and mysterious character throughout the novel. It is only towards the end of the book that we (and Blanche) begin to see beneath her protective outer shell and are finally given some glimpses of the real Jenny Bonnet.

The sense of time and place is very strong. I’m not sure I’ve read a book set in 1870s San Francisco before and I found it a vivid, atmospheric setting. The action takes place during both a heat wave and an epidemic of smallpox and both have an impact on Blanche’s story. Another interesting element of the novel is the role of music. Many songs and rhymes are quoted from in the book and information on each of them is given in an appendix. I thought this really added something to the story, helping to provide context and historical background. As Blanche and the other main characters are French and often use French slang, there is a glossary provided at the back of the book too, if you need help in translating any unfamiliar words.

My only criticism of this book is that the way the story is structured could cause confusion. It follows two time periods – one in Blanche’s present, describing Jenny’s murder and its consequences; the other flashing back to the beginning of their friendship a month earlier. Gradually the two storylines converge until they are only a day or two apart and at this point it becomes slightly difficult to follow the chronological sequence of events. Sometimes we are given the date, but not always, so it’s not immediately clear which thread of the story we are reading.

One other thing I should mention is that as Blanche is an exotic dancer there are some quite graphic descriptions of her work. It was maybe a bit excessive, but I could appreciate that it was all part of who Blanche is and it would have been hard to convey the realities of her life without being explicit at times.

Frog Music is not a book that will appeal to everyone (though you could say the same about any book, I suppose) but I thought it was great and having enjoyed this one and Room I’ll be looking for more of Emma Donoghue’s books soon.

19 thoughts on “Frog Music by Emma Donoghue

  1. Joanne says:

    I like the sound of this and will put it on my TBR list (love the cover too). I heard great things about Room, but didn’t read it, because I was nervous of the subject matter, it seemed like it might be distressing. I think I will read it at some point in the future, just not yet.

    • Helen says:

      The cover’s very striking, isn’t it? Room hadn’t really appealed to me at first, but I actually found it less upsetting than I’d expected so I was glad I had read it.

  2. tanya (52 books or bust) says:

    I’ve never read anything by Donoghue. Shameful I know. The premise of her novels never really do it for me, but everyone raves about her writing. I gotta do it some day and Frog Music may be the one that makes me jump.

    • Helen says:

      The premise of her books never sound all that appealing to me either, but once I start reading them I find I enjoy them. I hope you’ll decide to try Frog Music!

  3. Lark says:

    It’s a great title. And that time period is one of my favorites. Add in a real-life mystery and I’m definitely giving this one a try. 🙂 Thanks for the warning about the graphic bits. And for the review. I always meant to read Donoghue’s The Room, but haven’t gotten around to it yet. Maybe I’ll start with this book.

  4. Jo says:

    Like you I have only read Room. But I remain intrigued by her other work. This sounds like an interesting read and I heard her being interviewed on the radio so will definitely give it a go as there is something about the historical fiction element which appeals to me.

    • Helen says:

      This book is very different from Room, but I enjoyed it more because I love historical fiction. I’m curious about her other books now too.

    • Helen says:

      I haven’t read any of her previous historical fiction novels yet but I thought she captured the time and place very well in this one. I must look for one of her others!

  5. Heather says:

    I loved Room but didn’t fall as much in love with her short story collection, Astray. I do enjoy her writing a lot though, and historical fiction is definitely up my alley. I should really check this one out.

    • Helen says:

      I’m not really a fan of short stories so I’m not sure if I want to try Astray. I’ll look for more of her historical novels though, since I enjoyed this one so much.

Please leave a comment. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.