An Accidental Tragedy: The Life Of Mary, Queen Of Scots by Roderick Graham

An Accidental Tragedy The death of Mary, Queen of Scots, executed in 1587, could certainly be considered a tragedy. Was it also an accidental one? Could Mary’s fate have been avoided if she had only been a different type of person and if she had made different choices in life? This is the starting point for Roderick Graham’s 2009 biography of one of Scotland’s most fascinating monarchs, which claims ‘neither to blacken her character by portraying her as a murderess of husbands, nor to sanctify her as the lonely champion of her faith, but to recount the circumstances which formed her character and to explain the events which determined her fate’.

The book begins with Mary’s birth at Linlithgow Palace in 1542 and her rapid accession to the throne when her father, James V of Scotland, died just six days later. Mary was not Scotland’s first child monarch – James V himself and all of the four kings before him also came to the throne at an early age – and the Scottish people had become used to long periods of regency. As Graham explains, this led to an increase in the power and independence of the nobility and caused division and a lack of unity.

After a marriage treaty between Mary and Henry VIII’s son, Prince Edward, was rejected by the Scots, the five-year-old queen was sent to France where she would eventually marry the French king’s heir, the Dauphin Francis. Mary grew up in France rather than Scotland and she and Francis were strongly influenced by her mother’s relatives, the Guises. This meant that when Mary returned to Scotland to rule in 1561 following her husband’s death, she had very little knowledge of the country of her birth. At a time of increasing religious and political conflict among the Scottish noblemen a strong leader was needed.

Roderick Graham does a good job of showing how poorly equipped Mary was for her role as Queen of Scots and how she was unable to provide the sort of leadership the country required. Despite the presence of three influential women in her life – her mother, Mary of Guise; the Queen of France, Catherine de’ Medici; and the King of France’s mistress, Diane de Poitiers – Mary appeared to learn very little from any of them regarding the management of court intrigue and politics. The years that followed her return to Scotland were dominated by murders, plots, rebellions and two disastrous marriages, the first to Lord Darnley and the second to the Earl of Bothwell, finally ending in her abdication and imprisonment in England.

I found it interesting that Graham had chosen to write a book about someone for whom he seemed to have so little admiration, sympathy or liking. He never misses an opportunity to compare Mary with that other queen south of the border – Elizabeth I – and to point out how much stronger, cleverer and wittier the Queen of England was. In contrast, he paints a picture of Mary as immature, incapable of making good decisions and driven by passion and emotion. I’m not sure how fair or unfair his treatment of Mary is, but despite his preference for Elizabeth, he still made me feel sad for Mary as her life drew closer to its tragic end.

An Accidental Tragedy is the first book I’ve read that is specifically about Mary, Queen of Scots. Of course, I’ve come across her in other non-fiction books about the Tudor/Elizabethan period and she has been a secondary character in some of the historical fiction novels I’ve read, but this is the first time I’ve read a comprehensive biography of her entire life. I was particularly interested in reading about this period in Scotland’s history because my favourite historical fiction series, the Lymond Chronicles by Dorothy Dunnett, is set during the first part of Mary’s reign, but this just added another layer of interest to what was already a fascinating and very readable biography.

If anyone has any other biographies of Mary to recommend, please let me know. I would love to read another one.

12 thoughts on “An Accidental Tragedy: The Life Of Mary, Queen Of Scots by Roderick Graham

  1. Nish says:

    I liked Jean Plaidy’s books on her. She portrayed her in a very sympathetic while not glossing over her mistakes. You could try those.

  2. kaggsysbookishramblings says:

    I’m always slightly wary of biographies where the author patently doesn’t like the subject – I find myself wondering what the motivation was in writing it, for a start! Mary I think must have been a complex and interesting character, whatever her flaws, and Elizabeth was no saint! I tend to read more than one book about a subject if I’m interested – that way I can try and get a balance.

    • Helen says:

      I found this book interesting because so much of the information was new to me, but I do think the author let his personal opinion of Mary get in the way of giving a balanced view.

  3. margaretskea Author of prize winning historical novel Turn of the Tide says:

    Antonia Fraser’s excellent biography is perhaps the best known and has certainly been very well regarded for many years.

  4. jessicabookworm says:

    Sounds fascinating. I have always found it rather annoying how most things I’ve ever read or watched tends to paint Mary as polar opposites, either really negative or a complete innocent. I would like to read something more balanced.

    • Helen says:

      Yes, everyone seems to have a strong opinion on Mary one way or the other. I’m sure the truth was probably somewhere between the two.

  5. piningforthewest says:

    You should definitely read the Antonia Fraser book, it’s very good. Mind you I do think that Mary would have been better off if she had been a bit more like Elizabeth and eschewed husbands.

    • Helen says:

      I’m looking forward to reading the Antonia Fraser book, though I do have to be in the right mood for non-fiction. And yes, things would have been very different for Mary without the husbands!

  6. Fleur in her World says:

    This sounded like such an interesting premise, and it’s such a shame the author lacked empathy with his subject. I read and admired the Antonia Fraser book years ago, and I really enjoyed John Guy’s more recent book ‘My Heart is my Own.’

Please leave a comment. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.