Church of Marvels, published in 2015, is Leslie Parry’s first and, so far, her only novel but I enjoyed it so much I hope she will be writing more. It’s a dark, complex and unusual story set in New York City in 1895 and, despite comparisons with The Night Circus, I think it’s a very different sort of book.
There are three main characters to get to know. First there’s Sylvan Threadgill, a ‘night-soil collector’ who makes his living from cleaning privies, as well as fighting in the occasional amateur boxing match. One night, Sylvan finds a newborn baby girl who has been abandoned and left to lie in the dirt of the street. He rescues the baby and, as an orphan himself, resolves to find out what has happened to her parents.
Next, there’s Odile Church, who performs in a Coney Island sideshow as the girl on the wheel of death – spinning in circles as a blindfolded man throws knives in her direction. Odile is trying to come to terms with the tragic death of her mother in a fire and the disappearance of her twin sister Belle, a sword-swallower and contortionist, who has run away to Manhattan with no explanation. Worried about her sister’s state of mind, Odile decides it’s time to go and look for her.
Finally, we meet Alphie, an undertaker’s wife, who has found herself imprisoned in Blackwell’s Island Lunatic Asylum. She can’t remember how she came to be there, but she’s sure it’s part of a plot dreamed up by her mother-in-law who has never liked her and wants her out of her son’s life.
At first these felt like three completely separate storylines and I couldn’t see how they could be connected in any way. Of course they do eventually come together and then I could appreciate how cleverly structured the whole novel is, with things being revealed only when we really need to know them and the biggest plot twists kept until near the end of the book. For this reason, I can’t discuss some of the most intriguing aspects of the novel, but I will say that there is a lot going on and that there is much more to each of the characters above than meets the eye!
The circus element, which is probably one of the things that draws a lot of readers to this novel, is actually a fairly small part of the story and only a few scenes are set at Coney Island. Most of the action takes place in New York and, more specifically, in the dark side of New York, a world of asylums, opium dens and underground tunnels. The people who populate these dark and unpleasant places are those who are considered to be social outcasts; misfits; men, women and children who are ‘different’ in some way. Odile, Belle, Sylvan and Alphie all fit into this category and I had a lot of sympathy for each of them – life has not been easy for them and all they want is to have a chance of happiness.
Although it is certainly not the most cheerful or uplifting of novels, I found Church of Marvels a fascinating read and, as I’ve said, I would love to read more by Leslie Parry.
12 thoughts on “Church of Marvels by Leslie Parry”
I’m glad that you mentioned that the circus doesn’t play a huge part in this book as I’ve never liked them, not even as a child. I might give this one a go. Thanks.
I think it would be worth trying, as it’s only really the first few chapters that are set at the circus; most of the book focuses on the characters and their lives in New York.
I’d forgotten about this book. I always meant to read it, but it somehow got lost among my many To Read lists. Glad you reminded me about it. 🙂
I meant to read it when it was first published, then I forgot about it too. There were just so many other books needing to be read!
I didn’t like The Night Circus as much as a lot of other people, but I might try this one.
I wasn’t really a big fan of The Night Circus either. I enjoyed this book much more than that one.
Hmm…The circus not being a prominent element has turned me off. I like the fictional life of circuses. This one sounds kind of dark.
Yes, it is much darker than I thought it would be. I think if you picked this book up expecting a book about a circus you might be disappointed, as the circus is really just a starting point for exploring the lives of the characters.
Late 19th century New York City…I’m putting this on my tbr list ❤
The setting is fascinating…I’m glad it’s going on your tbr!
I have always meant to read this and thank you for reminding me. It sounds quite like my kind of book.
Yes, I think you might like this one, Judy.