2018 has been an eventful year in many ways and in November we marked the one hundredth anniversary of the end of the First World War. I picked up Deborah Carr’s new novel, The Poppy Field, to read over the centenary weekend, but I’ve since fallen behind with my reviews, which is why I’m only posting about it now.
The Poppy Field has two narratives, one set in 2018 and the other in 1916-18. First, in the present day, we meet Gemma, a British trauma nurse who has taken some time away from her stressful job to work on the renovation of a farmhouse in Doullens, in Northern France. Her father has recently inherited it and wants to get it into a good enough condition to be able to sell. With the help of Tom, a man she meets in Doullens who offers to assist with the building work, Gemma begins the long and difficult task of restoring the house to its former beauty. During the refurbishment, they discover a bundle of old letters dating back to World War I, written by an Alice Le Breton, and as soon as Gemma settles down to start reading them, she becomes obsessed with finding out how Alice’s story will end.
The other thread of the novel follows Alice, a young woman from Jersey in the Channel Islands, who volunteers as a VAD nurse at a casualty clearing station near Doullens during the war. Working conditions at the station are challenging and often horrifying, as wounded soldiers are brought in from the front line and the doctors and nurses do their best to save lives with the limited medication and equipment available to them. In the midst of so much pain and suffering, Alice is still able to find some happiness when she falls in love with one of her patients – but in times of war life is uncertain and Alice knows that her dreams could be shattered in an instant.
Although Alice and Gemma are very different people, there are many parallels between their stories – they are both nurses, they have both reached important turning points in their lives, and they have both found themselves in the same part of France. They also each become involved in a romance, but while I found Alice’s very moving (as wartime romances usually are), I thought Gemma’s was less convincing and very predictable. She meets the man who will become her love interest almost as soon as she arrives in France and there’s no real suspense involved in wondering whether they will end up together or not. Gemma’s whole storyline felt like little more than a frame for Alice’s, but I find that’s often the case with dual-time period novels and I almost always prefer one narrative over the other.
Although I’d hoped for more from this book, I did still enjoy it, particularly the historical sections and the details of Alice’s nursing work. The two separate threads of the story tie together nicely towards the end and the novel as a whole is an interesting and poignant read.
Thanks to HarperImpulse for providing a copy of this book for review via NetGalley.
11 thoughts on “The Poppy Field by Deborah Carr”
I prefer single narrative stories to dual narrative ones, too. But this one does sound good. And what a great cover! I’m adding this one to my list. 😀
Yes, I think it’s a lovely cover. 🙂
This sounds pretty good, and I don’t mind dual narratives at all.
I don’t mind dual narratives either, but I tend to find one more enjoyable than the other (usually the historical one).
I sometimes like dual narratives, but I’m beginning to agree with some people that the device is being used too much.
I often like dual narratives too, but sometimes I think the modern day storyline feels unnecessary and I would have preferred just the historical one.
Yes, I almost think some writers are falling into it because of laziness. It’s more difficult to write one story line than two.
I do like the sound of this and always like a dual narrative but I do feel that sometimes I am rushing through one section to get back to the better of the two.
I think the dual narrative structure works very well in some books, but isn’t really necessary in others. With this book, I definitely found the wartime sections much stronger.
Helen, I don’t tend to read a lot of books set during the World Wars – I’m not sure why – but I do like the sound of this. As you know, I love a good dual-narrative book. Like you though, I usually find myself more gripped by the past thread.
I love books set during the World Wars, especially the First World War. I enjoyed this one, but it was definitely the thread set in the past that was the most interesting.