The Mysterious Mr Badman by W.F. Harvey

The British Library are doing a great job of bringing the work of obscure or long-forgotten authors back into print with their Crime Classics series and William Fryer Harvey is another. Better known for his horror stories such as The Beast with Five Fingers and August Heat, he also wrote a crime novel, The Mysterious Mr Badman, which was originally published in 1934. I was immediately drawn to this book not just by the title, but also the subtitle, A Yorkshire Bibliomystery!

As Martin Edwards points out in the introduction, this must be the only crime novel with a blanket manufacturer as the protagonist. His name is Athelstan Digby and as the novel opens he is visiting his nephew in the Yorkshire village of Keldstone. One day he offers to take charge of the village bookshop so the bookseller and his wife can go to a funeral. Digby is expecting a quiet, uneventful afternoon so he is amazed when three men separately enter the shop within the space of a few hours, all asking for a copy of the same book: Bunyan’s Life and Death of Mr Badman. Digby is unable to find this book on the shelves, but when a boy arrives at the shop later that day with a pile of old books to sell – including Mr Badman – he becomes even more suspicious. What is going on – and why is that particular book so important?

This is a short novel, so I won’t go into the plot in much more detail…except to say that it’s great fun. There are murders, incriminating letters, political conspiracies, a touch of romance and a lot of humour! With character names like Athelstan Digby, Euphemia Upstart, Olaf Wake and Kitchener Lilywhite, you can see that it’s not a book to be taken entirely seriously, but at the same time it’s a clever, interesting and well written novel and one of the most enjoyable I’ve read from the British Library Crime Classics series for a while. Just be aware that it’s more of a thriller than a conventional detective novel; the mystery is actually solved quite early in the book and the significance of Mr Badman and the identity of the villain are revealed much sooner than you would expect. The fun is in watching Digby team up with his nephew Jim Pickering and Jim’s love interest Diana Conyers to try to decide what they should do with the information they’ve obtained.

As always when I read mysteries written in this period, I was struck by not only how much more difficult some aspects of crime-solving were in those days (no internet, no DNA testing) but also how much easier other aspects were. It was far simpler to trace a particular car when there were so few of them on the roads and everyone would notice an unfamiliar one driving through their village. I really enjoyed watching Digby, Jim and Diana investigate the mystery using the methods available to them in the 1930s, even if they occasionally walk straight into traps that are quite obvious to anyone who reads a lot of Golden Age crime fiction! I also loved the Yorkshire setting, although not all of the novel is set there.

Although, as I’ve said, Harvey is better known as a horror writer, it seems that the character of Digby previously appeared in a book of short stories, The Misadventures of Athelstan Digby. I hope that one will become available as a BLCC book soon too.

17 thoughts on “The Mysterious Mr Badman by W.F. Harvey

  1. Cyberkitten says:

    I’ve been browsing through the BLCC List lately. There’s 112 books now! It is great when organisations like this bring back ‘lost’ or forgotten classics to a new audience. I don’t have this one (yet) but I’ll probably pick it up at some point. Nice to see a mystery that doesn’t take place in London or the South-East!

    I’ve just started collecting a new classic series published by the Imperial War Museum of books published in and around WW2. It’s not all combat related but also covers the Home Front and much besides. Only 13 so far but I guess that’ll expand.

    …and in case you’ve missed it, I’ve just reviewed ‘V2’ by Robert Harris.

    https://cyberkittenspot.blogspot.com/2022/12/just-finished-reading-v2-by-robert.html

    • Helen says:

      Yes, it’s impossible to keep up with the BLCC list, they’re adding to it so quickly! I hope you’re able to read this one soon – it’s excellent and definitely a nice change to have a Yorkshire setting.

      The Imperial War Museum series sounds good. I’ve just had a look and I would be interested in reading some of those.

  2. Lark says:

    Can’t wait to read this one! I love revisiting these classic mysteries, and I’m so glad they’ve been reprinted. They’re always so much fun. I hope to read more of them next year. 😀

  3. FictionFan says:

    Ooh, this does sound good! I had pretty high hopes already because I’ve enjoyed his horror stories before, so I knew he could write. I think I may have to change my name to Euphemia Upstart…

    • Helen says:

      It’s great – and thankfully not one of those mysteries that become bogged down with alibis and timetables. I’ll have to try his horror stories sometime.

Please leave a comment. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.