This month Joanne of Portobello Book Blog is hosting Reading Scotland, so my Historical Musings post for November has a Scottish theme! I’ve listed below some of the historical fiction novels I’ve read with Scottish settings – many, though not all, are also written by Scottish authors.
Let’s start with some classic historical novels. I’ve read two of Sir Walter Scott’s books set in Scotland – The Heart of Midlothian and Redgauntlet. I particularly enjoyed the latter, which imagines a fictitious third Jacobite rising and includes a wonderful ghost story, Wandering Willie’s Tale. Also about the Jacobites (and another book I loved) is The Master of Ballantrae by Robert Louis Stevenson, which follows the rivalry between two Scottish brothers on opposite sides of the rebellion. Another classic is The Scottish Chiefs by Jane Porter, which was published in 1809 and tells the story of Scottish hero William Wallace.
My absolute favourite books set in Scotland are the Lymond Chronicles by Dorothy Dunnett. Published between 1961 and 1975, these six novels follow the adventures of Scottish nobleman Francis Crawford of Lymond in 16th century Europe and beyond. Make sure you start with The Game of Kings. Some of the books in her House of Niccolò series are also set at least partly in Scotland and so is her standalone novel, King Hereafter, which is based on the theory that Macbeth and Thorfinn, Earl of Orkney, were the same person. Speaking of Macbeth, I’ve read several other novels that are also inspired by the real history behind Shakespeare’s characters. Lady Macbethad by Isabelle Schuler, Blood Queen by Joanna Courtney and The Three Witches by Elena Collins are a few of them (although none are as good as King Hereafter).
Another Scottish author I would highly recommend is Andrew Greig. He writes beautifully and his novels Fair Helen, based on a Scottish Border Ballad, and Rose Nicolson, about the poet William Fowler, both really impressed me.
There are lots of historical novels about Mary, Queen of Scots, of course, and The Queen’s Mary by Sarah Gristwood, The Queen’s Caprice by Marjorie Bowen and The Tower by Flora Carr are just three that I’ve read. The King’s Witches by Kate Foster features another Queen of Scotland – Anne of Denmark, who married James VI. If you’d rather read about a Scottish king, you could try the Robert the Bruce trilogy by Robyn Young, which begins with Insurrection.
The Outlander series by Diana Gabaldon is obviously very popular. I have mixed feelings about it – I loved the first three books, which are mostly set (or at least anchored) in 18th century Scotland, but after the action moves mainly to America from the fourth book on, I felt that things began to get too complicated, with far too many new characters and subplots. I will still finish the series, though; the tenth and final book is apparently on its way, possibly in 2027. The only ones I’ve reviewed on my blog are An Echo in the Bone, Written in My Own Heart’s Blood and Go Tell the Bees That I Am Gone.
Most of Sally Magnusson’s novels are set in Scotland and cover some interesting topics such as the construction of the Loch Katrine Waterworks in The Ninth Child and the Highland Clearances in Music in the Dark. Some of Shona MacLean’s books also have Scottish settings; in The Cromarty Library Circle a group of people form a circulating library in a small Black Isle town, while The Bookseller of Inverness is another Jacobite novel and I still need to read her first book, The Redemption of Alexander Seaton.
Husband and wife team Chris Brookmyre and Dr Marisa Haetzman have written an excellent series of historical mysteries under the pseudonym Ambrose Parry set in 19th century Edinburgh. Starting with The Way of All Flesh, the series follows Dr Will Raven, assistant to the great Scottish obstetrician James Simpson, and Sarah Fisher, who dreams of one day becoming a doctor herself. Medicine of a different sort is featured in Vanessa Tait’s The Pharmacist’s Wife and The Resurrectionist by A Rae Dunlap. Also set in Edinburgh, but in the 1940s this time, are In Place of Fear and The Edinburgh Murders by Catriona McPherson, and Kate Foster’s The Mourning Necklace is about an 18th century woman who survives being hanged in Edinburgh’s Grassmarket. If you would prefer to read a book set in Glasgow, try Gillespie and I by Jane Harris, which I thought was great fun! Her first novel, The Observations, is also very entertaining.
The various Scottish islands are also popular settings for historical fiction. The Winter Isles by Antonia Senior is about Somerled, a 12th century ruler and warrior sometimes known as Lord of the Isles; Clear by Carys Davies follows a minister who is sent to evict the sole remaining inhabitant from an isolated Scottish island; and The Metal Heart by Caroline Lea describes the building of a chapel in the Orkney Islands by Italian prisoners of war. There’s also Now We Shall Be Entirely Free by Andrew Miller, a beautifully written book set partly in the Hebrides, and Anna Mazzola’s The Story Keeper, in which a woman visits the Isle of Skye to collect folk tales.
This post is getting very long, but here are a few other historical novels set in Scotland I really need to mention before I finish. First, His Bloody Project by Graeme Macrae Burnet, dealing with a triple murder committed in a Highlands village, then there’s The Vanished Days by Susanna Kearsley, set against the backdrop of the failed Darien Scheme and the events leading to the Act of Union. Corrag by Susan Fletcher is about the Glencoe Massacre of 1692 and a girl accused of witchcraft, while the battle of Flodden and its aftermath is covered in Rosemary Goring’s After Flodden and Dacre’s War.
Have you read any of these – or would you like to? Can you recommend any other historical fiction set in Scotland?
