In 2012 I read my first Walter Scott novel, Ivanhoe, and was surprised by how much I enjoyed it. Having found Scott less difficult to read than I’d expected, I decided to add another of his books to my Classics Club list and something drew me to this one – possibly memories of the Scottish football results being announced on the television on a Saturday afternoon (Heart of Midlothian is the name of an Edinburgh team).
The novel – which predates the football team, being published in 1818 – takes its title from the Old Tolbooth Prison in Edinburgh, which was in the heart of the county of Midlothian. Scott based his plot on two real historical events: the Porteous Riots of 1736 and the story of a young woman who walked all the way to London to obtain a royal pardon for her sister who had been wrongly charged with infanticide. In Scott’s version, the young woman’s name is Jeanie Deans and she lives on a dairy farm at St Leonard’s Crags with her father, Davie, a strict Cameronian (a Presbyterian faction).
Jeanie’s younger sister, Euphemia – known as Effie – is in the Tolbooth facing the death penalty, having been accused of giving birth in secret and murdering her newborn child. Jeanie is sure Effie is innocent, but with no witnesses to the pregnancy or the birth and no way to prove what happened to the baby, she is guilty in the eyes of the law. If Jeanie would only tell the court that she had known her sister was pregnant, Effie could be freed, but she is unwilling to tell a lie and instead she decides to go to London to ask Queen Caroline for a pardon. Armed with a letter of introduction to the Duke of Argyll and some money borrowed from an admirer, the Laird of Dumbiedikes, Jeanie sets off on foot to save her sister’s life.
The first half of the novel sets the scene, describing a riot that breaks out in Edinburgh during a protest over the hanging of two smugglers. When Captain John Porteous orders the city guard to fire into the crowd, causing the deaths of several people, he himself is imprisoned in the Tolbooth. The prison is then stormed by a mob and Porteous is lynched and killed. These events become entwined with Effie’s story and provide the historical backdrop for the novel. The second half of the book concentrates on Jeanie’s journey to London, which includes encounters with some characters we previously met in Scotland: George Robertson, the father of Effie’s child; and Meg Murdockson and her mentally ill daughter, Madge Wildfire, two women who could hold the key to the mystery of the missing baby.
Well, The Heart of Midlothian was not the relatively easy read that Ivanhoe was! I found it much more challenging, for several reasons. First, as the novel is set mainly in Scotland, the dialogue is written almost entirely in Scots. I wouldn’t normally have a problem with this, but added to the fact that the book was written in the early 1800s, it did slow down the pace of my reading quite a lot. I find that whenever a book uses a large amount of dialect – even one you’re familiar with – a little more effort is required to read it and that was definitely the case here. If you think you might struggle with the dialect, I would recommend choosing an edition of the book with a good glossary!
Also, unlike Ivanhoe, which is a medieval adventure story packed with sword fights, sieges, villainous knights and feuding noblemen, this is a very different type of novel. While Jeanie’s personal story was gripping, I have to admit I had very little interest in the long passages describing the religious situation in eighteenth century Scotland and the discussions between Jeanie’s father, Davie Deans, and his neighbours on their different moral beliefs. I also thought the plot relied too heavily on coincidence, with Jeanie meeting people from her own small community in Scotland hundreds of miles away in England – and I felt that the final few chapters of the book were unnecessary as the story had already reached a more natural ending point.
I did enjoy parts of The Heart of Midlothian, though. Jeanie is a strong heroine who behaves with honesty and integrity throughout the novel, and although some of her choices were frustrating, I did like her. There is a romantic interest for Jeanie too – the schoolmaster, Reuben Butler – but this only forms a small part of the story. I was also interested in the descriptions of eighteenth century life and the relationship between Scotland and England in the years following the union of 1707. And there are plenty of memorable scenes, from the storming of the Tolbooth near the beginning to Jeanie’s meeting with Queen Caroline, wife of George II, towards the end.
I certainly didn’t love this book the way I loved Ivanhoe, but I’ll still read more of Scott’s novels and will hope that the next one I pick up is more to my taste than this one was!
15 thoughts on “The Heart of Midlothian by Sir Walter Scott”
The Scots dialect books are tough, but I have read several, and I enjoyed them more than Ivanhoe. Maybe it’s just that I dislike pasteboard Rowena so much and like Jessica.
I liked Ivanhoe better than this book because I preferred the medieval setting, but I do agree with you about Rowena!
I wouldn’t have a problem with the dialect but I think I’ll read The Bride of Lammermuir before this one. I prefer Jessica to Rowena too.
I’m sure you would have an easier time with this book than I did! I don’t usually have any trouble understanding Scots (I think being from Newcastle probably helps) but there was so much of it in this book I found I had to really concentrate.
I really must try more of Scott’s novels. I loved Ivanhoe but have never tried anything else, and sadly that was so many years ago now! Perhaps I should start with a re-read 🙂
I’m glad you loved Ivanhoe too. I would like to re-read it one day, but not until I’ve tried some more of his books first.
I was just in Edinburgh and saw the Heart of Midlothian stones, which are embedded in the pavement outside St Giles’ Cathedral in the place where the condemned cell of Tolbooth Prison used to stand. This would have made a brilliant accompaniment to the trip!
What a coincidence! I’ll have to go and look at the stones next time I’m in Edinburgh.
I had the same experience; I read Ivanhoe and really loved it, and then read The Heart of Midlothian. I found it quite challenging too, and some passages were quite long and tedious. Jeanie was definitely an interesting character, though, and I love the story itself, her travelling all the way to London to ask for a pardon.
Yes, I loved Jeanie’s story too, but the book was definitely very tedious in places! It hasn’t put me off wanting to read more of Scott’s novels, though.
Wonderful review. I’ve never read Scott and always intended Ivanhoe to be the first. I may have to rethink that.
I found Ivanhoe much more fun to read, but Heart of Midlothian is probably a better book. I hope you enjoy whichever one you choose to start with.
I read Heart of Midlothian a long time ago. It was challenging to read, but I was captured by the characters. I’ve never read Ivanhoe but it’s on my TBR lists. My first Scott book was Waverly, which was also difficult but worthwhile.
Ivanhoe is a lot of fun to read – I hope you enjoy it!