Philippa Carr’s Daughters of England, Volumes 1-3

The Daughters of England Philippa Carr is one of the pseudonyms of the author also known as Jean Plaidy, Victoria Holt and others. As Victoria Holt she wrote gothic romance/suspense novels, as Jean Plaidy she wrote more serious historical fiction and it seems that her Philippa Carr books are somewhere between the two. The Daughters of England is a long series of twenty novels following successive generations of one family from the sixteenth century to the twentieth, where the narrator of each book is the daughter of the narrator from the previous one. The series was originally published between 1972 and 1995 but has now been released in ebook format by Open Road Media and I received the first three volumes from the publisher through Netgalley in the form of a 3-in-1 book, which is why I’ve waited until I’ve finished all three before writing my review.

The Miracle at St Bruno’s is where it all begins. Our narrator is Damask Farland, the daughter of a rich lawyer, who grows up in Tudor England during the reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI and Queen Mary I, a time of political and religious change. The story revolves around Damask’s relationship with Bruno, a boy from the neighbouring St Bruno’s Abbey who believes he must be a miracle child because he was found as a baby in the Abbey’s Christmas crib.

This was a good introduction to the series and an excellent portrayal of what life was like during this time period. While Damask and her family may have been secure and prosperous during the reign of one monarch, as soon as the next one came to the throne with his or her different religious views, their safety was no longer guaranteed. I did find the plot very predictable and could see every ‘surprising’ revelation and dramatic twist coming a mile away, but maybe I’ve just read too many of this type of book!

Book Two, The Lion Triumphant, is the story of Damask’s daughter, Cat Kingsman, and is an exciting historical adventure novel. The setting this time is Elizabethan England and with the country preparing to defend itself against the Spanish Armada, England’s brave sailors are the heroes of the day. One of these sailors, Jake Pennlyon, captain of the Rampant Lion, is determined to make Cat his wife. Cat does everything in her power to convince him that she will never marry him, but when she is captured and taken aboard a Spanish galleon bound for Tenerife she finds herself at the mercy of Don Felipe, the Governor of the Canary Islands, who has sworn revenge against Jake and the woman he loves.

This was a great story and my favourite of the three books, though I actually felt guilty for enjoying it so much because the ‘hero’ is such a violent, arrogant man. Despite the female protagonists and the focus on history from a woman’s perspective, these really aren’t good books from a feminist point of view. Even by sixteenth century standards I’m not sure Jake’s behaviour (and Colum Casvellyn’s in the next volume) would have been considered acceptable! Still, at least Jake does have some redeeming qualities, unlike Colum…

The third book in the series, The Witch from the Sea, is narrated by Cat’s daughter, Linnet. With the Armada defeated and the Elizabethan era coming to an end, Linnet’s father is planning to set up a trading company with a friend, Fennimore Landor. It is expected that Linnet will marry Fennimore…until the night she is abducted by local squire Colum Casvellyn. Colum is a character who makes Jake Pennlyon seem like a saint, yet Linnet is attracted to him and eventually agrees to marry him.

Settling into Colum’s home, Castle Paling in Cornwall, Linnet gradually discovers exactly how her husband has made his fortune and is horrified by what she learns. Life at the castle becomes even more difficult for Linnet after a beautiful woman is found shipwrecked on the shore nearby and becomes part of the household. It will be left to Linnet’s daughter, Tamsyn, to solve the mysteries of Castle Paling and uncover the truth about the ‘witch from the sea’.

This book has a darker, more gothic feel than the first two, with descriptions of the castle and its haunted towers, shipwrecks, ghost stories, and the mysterious Halloween appearances and disappearances of the ‘witch’ Maria. It’s also a sad story at times, as we have to say goodbye to some of the characters who have been around for two or three books. Not as good as The Lion Triumphant, but I still enjoyed this one.

My verdict on the Daughters of England series:

These books will be too melodramatic and romance-based to appeal to everyone (especially if you can’t deal with the chauvinistic male characters and the way the women react to them), but I found them to be interesting, entertaining historical fiction novels and there’s no doubt that Philippa Carr has a good knowledge of the time periods she is writing about. While all three of these books focus on fictional characters and their personal stories, they have a strong historical background covering all the major events of the sixteenth and early seventeeth centuries. I had fun reading these three novels, particularly The Lion Triumphant, though I suspect I would probably have enjoyed them more when I was younger and just starting to get into historical fiction.

I would definitely like to continue with the series – but not immediately as even with their different settings the books do all seem to be very similar and reading three in such a short space of time was a bit too much for me. I’ll probably wait a while before picking up the fourth one, Saraband for Two Sisters.

12 thoughts on “Philippa Carr’s Daughters of England, Volumes 1-3

  1. Alex says:

    I loved Jean Plaidy as a teenager but didn’t get in with her as Victoria Holt. These sound a bit too Holt-like for my taste but it’s good to know that such writers are being reissued.

    • Helen says:

      I haven’t read many of her books under any name, but these do seem to be a sort of cross between the style of Holt and Plaidy. I’m pleased this whole series has been reissued as I’m sure I’ll want to continue with the next volume at some point.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Victoria Holt was always my favourite author. I have recently discovered these books and am enjoying them so much – I am at the moment on book 14. I am also learning a lot of history (and old Cornish customs!)

    • Helen says:

      I’m glad you’re still enjoying the series after 14 books. I’ve still only read the first three but am hoping to read the next one soon!

  3. Ginny says:

    I like Victoria Holt for a good “escape” read. About two years ago I decided to try the “Daughters of England” series and my reactions were very similar to yours (I completely agree with what you wrote about “The Lion Triumphant.”) But I have found that I have to read her books in small doses; if I try to read too many too close together, I start to find them utterly predictable. It’s been a while since my last “Daughters” book (I think I got to #5), so maybe it’s time to give the series another look.

    • Helen says:

      Thanks for commenting, Ginny. I enjoyed the first three books in this series and really must continue with the next one soon! I definitely agree that it’s best not to read them too close together, though, as they are quite predictable. Hope you enjoy the rest of the series!

  4. says:

    SPOILER ALERT… just started book 3…. book 1 was pretty good… in book 2, the protaganist falls in love with and marries her two rapists, and helps to raise the bastard children of her husband – while their mothers reside in her home…. i’m only 8% in with book 3, and already the heroine’s been drugged so her “rescuer” can do whatever he wants while she’s unable to consent… i think i’m continuing to read it just to see if my incredulity is justified…

    i read the fourth book some 30 years ago and i think i liked it, so i’ll give it till then before i throw my hands up in disgust… these books may be historical, but they sure as hell aren’t romantic…

    • Helen says:

      Thanks for your comment. I’m glad you liked Book 1, but I completely understand your feelings about Books 2 and 3. The way the heroines are treated by the male characters and the portrayal of rape in both books does feel very dated and uncomfortable for a modern reader to read. I enjoyed these books overall, but those aspects did bother me and I agree they’re not very ‘romantic’…though not all historical novels are, of course.

  5. Rashele Lashley-de Freitas says:

    I have real all the books in this series…twice!! I enjoyed the earlier ones better. Coming to the end like just about the last five books or so, the theme changed. It was still related but not in the order of the original plot. All in all I love these books and will probably read them in ten years again. I also have and read all of the books written under Victoria Holt as well.

    • Helen says:

      I’ve still only read the first three, but I do definitely plan to continue with the series eventually! It’s good to know that you loved them. I think I’ve only read one of her Victoria Holt books, so I still have plenty of those to look forward to. 🙂

  6. Wendy says:

    I have always loved Jean Plaidy, Philippa Carr and Victoria Holt. I had all of the Holt and Carr series and many Plaidy books. I lost all my books in a housefire and am recollecting all of them as I find them. You really know how much you enjoy your books when you don’t have them any more. As to the fire we did save our family albums and computer hard drive so all was not lost and we are uninjured. It was hardest losing books as I had a lot of them (thousand plus) and some of them were from my mother’s childhood. So happy to see that you are devoted to providing these treasures.

    • Helen says:

      I’m so sorry to hear that, Wendy. I’m glad you and your family weren’t injured, which is the most important thing, but it must have been terrible to lose so many books with special memories for you. It’s good that Open Road Media are making the Philippa Carr series available again.

Please leave a comment. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.