Guy Gavriel Kay is only a recent discovery for me, but after reading Tigana in June I knew I wanted to read more of his work. Leander of The Idle Woman mentioned that she had been wanting to re-read The Lions of Al-Rassan, one of her favourite books, so we decided it would be interesting to read it at the same time and exchange our thoughts on it.
I should start by saying that although Kay is known as a fantasy author, this book has few, if any, elements that I would describe as ‘fantasy’ and is much closer to historical fiction. The story is set in a fictitious world very similar to medieval Spain. In the north, we have the sun-worshipping Jaddites – brave warriors and horsemen. The Jaddite lands have become divided and weakened over the years due to rivalries between their three kings but they still hope to one day ride south and reconquer the rest of the peninsula. In the south is Al-Rassan, the land of the Asharites, who worship the stars and who value poetry, music and beauty. After the death of their last Khalif, Al-Rassan has also become divided and is not as strong as it once was. Caught between the two are the wandering Kindath people, who pray to the two moons that shine in the sky, one blue and one white. Even with my very limited (almost non-existent) knowledge of Spanish history I could immediately see that the Jaddites represented Christians, the Asharites Muslims and the Kindath Jews.
As tension builds between the Jaddites and the Asharites and war begins to look inevitable, there are big consequences for the novel’s three central characters. One of these is Rodrigo Belmonte, Captain to a Jaddite king and one of the Jaddites’ greatest soldiers. When Rodrigo is exiled by his king he and his company find themselves in the Asharite city of Ragosa. Here he meets another great man, Ammar ibn Khairan, an Asharite who is also in exile, and the two form an instant connection. Our third protagonist is a woman, Jehane bet Ishak, a Kindath physician who joins Rodrigo’s company and becomes close to both men. With the peninsula heading rapidly towards conflict, will the bonds between Rodrigo, Ammar and Jehane be able to survive?
Now that I’ve read two of Guy Gavriel Kay’s novels, it’s hard to say which I liked best because both were such great books. I think I found Tigana more fun to read (simply because I read fantasy so rarely these days and it was something a bit different for me to read a book with magic and wizards) but I found the writing in The Lions of Al-Rassan more powerful and the characters more fully developed. Ammar, Rodrigo and Jehane are all characters that I could love and admire, and considering their very different backgrounds and cultures, it’s quite an achievement that Kay could make it possible to identify with and care about all three of them.
Although this novel is set in a fictional land, the parallels with a real period of history made me feel that I was gaining a better understanding of medieval Spain. But as well as the history, there’s also a lot of drama and excitement throughout the novel: among other things, there are battles, assassination attempts (both successful and unsuccessful), and a masked Carnival. What I really loved about this book, though, was the portrayal of the three main characters and the relationships between them. It’s not as simple as Jehane being in love with both men (or them being in love with her) and having to choose between them; although there is a romantic aspect, the relationships are much deeper and more complex than that and encompass not just love but also friendship, loyalty and trust.
There’s a growing sense of sadness too as you start to approach the end of the book and wonder whether all three of Ammar, Jehane and Rodrigo will survive the coming conflict and how they will cope if they find themselves on opposite sides. The final chapter was one of the most tense and emotional I’ve read for some time, though I thought it would have been even more effective without the epilogue that followed (I was pleased to see that Leander felt the same as I was wondering whether I was the only person who would rather not have had the loose ends tied up).
I’m excited about the prospect of working my way through the rest of Kay’s books, but I’m sure I’ll want to re-read this one at some point too – preferably after I’ve had a chance to read up on Spanish history! If you would like to see what Leander thought of The Lions of Al-Rassan, you can read her post here.
17 thoughts on “The Lions of Al-Rassan by Guy Gavriel Kay”
Sounds like a great read. The fantasy/history style reminds me of A Song of Ice and Fire series. Once I’ve finished that epic series maybe I should look for this author’s work.
That series sounds like a big commitment so I can understand wanting to finish those before trying another fantasy author!
Yes, big commitment! I still have 5 to go and the author is writing more!
Thanks for all your posts, all are considered and appreciated. I will definitely read this book, after I finish Edith Parteger’s Heaven Tree trilogy, which I highly recommend. Guy Gavriel Kay wrings me out, so I have to gird my loins before I dive in. I loved ‘Finovar’s Tapestry, Ysabel and Under Heaven; although I felt utterly exhausted after reading Finovars Tapestry (actually 3 books, can’t remember all the titles) sorry…. But everything is there; pagan mythology, Arthurian legend, modern contemporary life, battles, large and small, intimate and epic and through it all, love and life. I read this book at a particular time in my life, and it made me weep. I know, I’m ridiculous, but there it is.
Thanks for reminding me I am not alone as I turn the pages late into the night.
No, you’re not alone! I’m thinking about making Under Heaven the next Kay novel I read, but I’d like to read them all eventually. The Heaven Tree trilogy is on my list too as I’ve heard such good things about those books.
So pleased to see the considered final verdict, Helen. And so relieved that you enjoyed it so much! It was a real joy discussing this with you – and it’s funny that we both independently picked up on the same things. I’d recommend Sailing to Sarantium or Under Heaven for your next one. 🙂
Thanks so much for letting me read along with you.
Yes, we seem to have had a lot of the same thoughts about the book. Thanks for suggesting the joint read 🙂
I’ve only read Ysabel which I really liked but is a bit different from his others which I’ve always thought of as fantasy. I do have Song of Arbonne on my shelf so maybe I should try it.
Yes, I’ve heard that Ysabel is not really a typical Guy Gavriel Kay book. I’m glad you still liked it, though.
I adore Kay’s books. I think The Lions of Al-Rassan is my favourite to date, but I have high hopes for River of Stars, which I just picked up from the library today.
I hope you enjoy River of Stars. I’m looking forward to reading that one but want to read Under Heaven first as they have the same setting.
Tigana is my favorite Kay book, with The Lions of Al-Rassan a close second, but A Song for Arbonne and the two Sarantine Mosaic books aren’t far behind. Really, the only one I didn’t enjoy much was the The Last Light of the Sun. I look forward to reading more reviews!
His books all sound so appealing! I’m sorry to hear you didn’t enjoy The Last Light of the Sun, though.
I love The Lions of Al-Rassan! I also like A Song for Arbonne. I rank them both above Tigana only because one of the female characters in Tigana really irked me and then somehow ended up in a completely out-of-nowhere romance at the end of the book and that made no sense to me.
I agree with you about the romance coming out of nowhere at the end of Tigana, although that alone didn’t spoil the rest of the book for me. I think I did prefer The Lions of Al-Rassan, though. I’m looking forward to reading A Song for Arbonne!