“The long petal of sea and wine and snow” is how the poet Pablo Neruda once described Chile, the country in which most of Isabel Allende’s latest novel is set, and Neruda himself plays a small but very important role in this epic story, based on true historical events.
Beginning in Spain in 1938, we meet Victor Dalmau, a young medical student from Barcelona, and Roser Bruguera, an orphan who has been taken in and raised by the Dalmau family. Roser is in love with Victor’s brother Guillem and is pregnant with his child, but like many others, they have their plans for the future destroyed by the civil war which is currently tearing Spain apart. Victor and Roser are Republicans, but when it becomes clear that General Franco and his Nationalists have won the war, they join half a million other refugees crossing the border into France in search of safety. It is here that they learn of Pablo Neruda’s plan to commission a ship, the Winnipeg, to transport two thousand of the refugees to Chile, where they will have a chance to build a new life. The only problem is, while Victor is offered a place on the ship due to his medical training, Roser’s skills are less in demand and she will only be allowed to join him if she can prove she is his wife…
A Long Petal of the Sea is the second book I’ve read by Isabel Allende. My first was The Japanese Lover and although I was disappointed by that one, I wanted to give her another chance to impress me. Sadly, I felt very much the same about this book and am coming to the conclusion that, despite her popularity, Allende is just not an author for me.
The story itself is fascinating. I have read very little about the Spanish Civil War and knew nothing about what happened in the aftermath, with Spanish refugees being placed in concentration camps on their arrival in France. I knew even less about the political history of Chile, which is the focus of the second half of the novel. I think My Beautiful Imperial by Rhiannon Lewis is the only other book I’ve read set in that country – but that story took place in a much earlier period than this one. It’s sad to think that refugees like Victor and Roser, who had already been through so much, would settle in Chile thinking they had found peace and safety, only to face more upheaval with the 1973 military coup and then years of dictatorship under General Pinochet.
My problem with this book was the style in which it was written. As with The Japanese Lover, I felt as though I was reading a long list of facts rather than a compelling story. I found it impossible to care about or engage with the characters because the author was just telling me how people thought and felt instead of showing me through their words and actions. This should have been a moving and emotional novel but instead I thought it was dry and impersonal and seemed much more like non-fiction than fiction.
I’m aware that Isabel Allende has a large and loyal fan base and other reviews of this book are overwhelmingly positive, so it’s obvious that I’m just not the right reader for Allende’s books. I’ve tried two now and I don’t think I need to try any more, but if you think this book sounds interesting don’t let me put you off reading it – you might be able to connect with it in a way that for some reason I just couldn’t.
Thanks to Bloomsbury for providing a copy of this book for review via NetGalley.
20 thoughts on “A Long Petal of the Sea by Isabel Allende”
I too want to root for a woman author, but I am with you. I never liked her as much as the big names, not because they are big names, but because of how much they move me, -Cortazar, Gabo -Marquez, Sabato, Vargas Llosa, Rulfo…I am glad she has her fans, LOL.
I’m glad it’s not just me who isn’t a fan! I will have to read some of the other authors you mention.
Good review. I have already requested it—it will be my first of her books. We shall see if it makes it past the one hour test.
I would be interested to know what you think of it. I hope you enjoy it a lot more than I did!
I read The House of the Spirits many years ago and remember loving it, but that is all that I’ve read by Allende. Patrons at the library always recommend her books to me, though, so I may give this one a go!
I suppose there’s a reason why The House of the Spirits is her most famous book, so I should probably have started with that one. I hope you enjoy this book if you do give it a go.
I read House of the Spirits in high school and wasn’t too taken with it. Try Nada by Carmen Laforet if you want to read a Spanish civil war story, it’s haunting and very character driven.
Oh, yes, Laforet! That’s more to my liking, definitely.
Thanks for the suggestion! I’ll definitely think about reading it.
Hmm, I’m tempted because of the Spanish Civil War coonection – as you know that’s my new challenge subject. But I have a feeling I’d probably react in a similar way to you to Allende’s style. I’m often tempted by the blurbs of her books, but when I read the reviews I usually come away thinking they’re not for me. I shall put this on the maybe list…
Well, a lot of other readers have enjoyed it so it might just be me. Allende’s books do always sound fascinating, but I’ll avoid the temptation in future!
This is interesting because I just read The House of the Spirits, having heard of Allende for years and being inspired by my Reading All Around the World project. I enjoyed it overall though I can see some of the weaknesses you point out – the action was very headlong, one thing after another, and there was a lot of “telling.” However there was a kind of raw energy to it that kept me going and the climax was emotionally wrenching. Wow.
I then read her 2003 memoir My Invented Country, which describes her relationship with Chile and the events in her life that led up to her writing that first novel. She says that had she not been an exile, she would never have become a writer. I found it all fascinating, being a world-history ignoramus as I am I knew hardly anything about Chile and its political drama. In this book Allende’s voice is different, more personal and engaging. The description of her path to becoming a writer was for me more interesting than the novel itself.
I don’t think I would have read it if I hadn’t been curious about the author behind the novel, but I’m very glad I did. You might consider giving it a try.
Good recommendation, it looks like a good memoir, definitely.
I forgot to mention that she has a dry humor which comes out here and is very funny. I do recommend it!
The memoir does sound appealing. Maybe I would get on better with that than I do with her fiction. Thanks for suggesting it.
I think with her it may come down to checking what’s better rated at Goodreads, hahaha. Seriously, when I see a book that seems worth reading, I check Goodreads, and I see a few people who I share taste and criteria with, who have read it, or want to read it, and a high rating.
With Umberto Ecco, I loved The Name of the Rose, enjoy a good chunk of his book about translation, but bought a book for not much that I turned back because it had lower ratings. My two cents.
I have only read a couple of books by Allende, but I have the impression that her earlier ones are much better than her more recent ones. You might try one of the books she is more well known for before giving up on her.
I might try The House of the Spirits one day but I’m not planning to read any more of her recent books.
I’ve read a few by Allende but not this or the Japanese Lover, I’m sorry you didn’t like them but give The House of the Spirits a go before you give up on her!
If I do decide to give Allende one more chance, The House of the Spirits will definitely be the one I choose!